9 replies to this topic

[Try Again]

Hello Everyone. In preparation to season 16, I thought it would be fun for us to rank the returning pros and their stars. Interesting fact that the following returning pros did not have a star eliminated first: Derek, Karina, Cheryl, Val

Derek Hough
1. Jennie Garth, Season 5 (4th Place)
2. Shannon Elizabeth, Season 6 (6th Place)
3. Brook Burke, Season 7 (1st Place)
4. Lil' Kim, Season 8 (5th Place)
5. Joanna Krupa, Season 9 (4th Place)
6. Nicole Scherzinger, Season 10 (1st Place)
7. Jennifer Grey, Season 11 (1st Place)
8. Ricki Lake, Season 13 (3rd Place)
9. Maria Menounos, Season 14 (4th Place)
10. Shawn Johnson, Season 15 (2nd Place)

Karina Smirnoff
1. Mario Lopez, Season 3 (2nd Place)
2. Billy Ray Cyrus, Season 4 (5th Place)
3. Floyd Mayweather Jr., Season 5 (9th Place)
4. Mario, Season 6 (5th Place)
5. Rocco DiSpirito, Season 7 (9th Place)
6. Steve Wozniak, Season 8 (10th Place)
7. Aaron Carter, Season 9 (5th Place)
8. Mike Sorrentino, Season 11 (9th Place)
9. Ralph Macchio, Season 12 (4th Place)
10. J.R. Martinez, Season 13 (1st Place)
11. Gavin De Graw, Season 14 (9th Place)
12. Apolo Anton Ohno, Season 15 (5th Place)


Peta Murgatroyd
1. Ron Artest, Season 13 (12th Place)
2. Donald Driver, Season 14 (1st Place)
3. Gilles Marini, Season 15 (6th Place)


Tony Dovolani
1. Stacey Kiebler, Season 2 (3rd Place)
2. Sara Evans, Season 3 (6th Place)
3. Leeza Gibbson, Season 4 (9th Place)
4. Jane Seymour, Season 5 (6th Place)
5. Marissa Jaret Winokur, Season 6 (4th Place)
6. Susan Lucci, Season 7 (6th Place)
7. Melissa Rycroft, Seasons 8 & 15 (3rd & 1st Place)
8. Kathy Ireland, Season 9 (14th Place)
9. Kate Gosselin, Season 10 (8th Place)
10. Audrina Patridge, Season 11 (7th Place)
11. Wendy Williams, Season 12 (10th Place)
12. Chynna Phillips, Season 13 (9th Place)
13. Martina Navratilova, Season 14 (12th Place)


Tristan MacManus
1. Nancy Grace, Season 13 (5th Place)
2. Gladys Knight, Season 14 (8th Place)
3. Pamela Anderson, Season 15 (12th Place)

Cheryl Burke
1. Drew Lachey, Season 2 (1st Place)
2. Emmitt Smith, Season 3 & 15th (1st & 4th Place)
3. Ian Ziering, Season 4 (4th Place)
4. Wayne Newton, Season 5 (10th Place)
5. Cristian de la Fuente, Season 6 (3rd Place)
6. Maurice Green, Season 7 (5th Place)
7. Gilles Marini, Season 8 (2nd Place)
8. Tom Delay, Season 9 (13th Place)
9. Chad Ochocinco, Season 10 (4th Place)
10. Rick Fox, Season 11 (6th Place)
11. Chris Jericho, Season 12 (7th Place)
12. Rob Kardashian, Season 13 (2nd Place)
13. William Levy, Season 14 (3rd Place)

Valentin Chmerkosvskiy
1. Elisabetta Canalis, Season 13 (11th Place)
2. Sherri Shepherd, Season 14 (10th Place)
3. Kelly Monaco, Season 15 (3rd Place)


Mark Ballas
1. Sabrina Bryan, Season 5 (7th Place)
2. Kristi Yamaguchi, Season 6 (1st Place)
3. Kim Kardashian, Season 7 (11th place)
4. Shawn Johnson, Season 8 (1st Place)
5. Melissa Joan Hart, Season 9 (9th Place)
6. Shannen Doherty, Season 10 (11th Place)
7. Bristol Palin, Season 11 & 15 (3rd & 9th)
8. Chelsea Kane, Season 12 (3rd Place)
9. Kristin Cavallari, Season 13 (10th Place)
10. Katherine Jenkins, Season 14 (2nd Place)


Kym Johnson
1. Jerry Springer, Season 3 (5th Place)
2. Joey Fatone, Season 4 & 15 (2nd & 12th Place)
3. Mark Cuban, Season 5 (8th Place)
4. Penn Jillette, Season 6 (12th Place)
5. Warren Sapp, Season 7 (2nd Place)
6. David Alan Grier, Season 8 (9th Place)
7. Donny Osmond, Season 9 (1st Place)
8. David Hasslehoff, Season 11 (12th Place)
9. Hines Ward, Season 12 (1st Place)
10. David Arquette, Season 13 (6th Place)
11. Jaleel White, Season 14 (7th Place)

Edited by Try Again, Mar 10, 2013 @ 3:07 PM.

[PBGamer89]

Derek Hough
1. Shawn Johnson, Season 15 (2nd Place)
2. Nicole Scherzinger, Season 10 (1st Place)
3. Jennifer Grey, Season 11 (1st Place)
4. Brooke Burke, Season 7 (1st Place)
5. Jennie Garth, Season 5 (4th Place)
6. Lil' Kim, Season 8 (5th Place)
7. Maria Menounos, Season 14 (4th Place)
8. Ricki Lake, Season 13 (3rd place)
9. Joanna Krupa, Season 9 (4th Place)
10. Shannon Elizabeth, Season 6 (6th Place)

Karina Smirnoff
1. J.R. Martinez, Season 13 (1st Place)
2. Apolo Anton Ohno, Season 15 (5th Place)
3. Mario Lopez, Season 3 (2nd Place)
4. Ralph Macchio, Season 12 (4th Place)
5. Mario, Season 6 (5th Place)
6. Aaron Carter, Season 9 (5th Place)
7. Rocco DiSpirito, Season 7 (9th Place)
8. Billy Ray Cyrus, Season 4 (5th Place)
9. Gavin De Graw, Season 14 (9th Place)
10. Steve Wozniak, Season 8 (10th Place)
11. Floyd Mayweather Jr., Season 5 (9th Place)
12. Mike Sorrentino, Season 11 (9th Place)

Peta Murgatroyd
1. Donald Driver, Season 14 (1st Place)
2. Gilles Marini, Season 15 (6th Place)
3. Ron Artest, Season 13 (12th Place)

Tony Dovolani
1. Melissa Rycroft, Seasons 8 & 15 (3rd & 1st Place)
2. Stacey Kiebler, Season 2 (3rd Place)
3. Marissa Jaret Winokur, Season 6 (4th Place)
4. Jane Seymour, Season 5 (6th Place)
5. Audrina Patridge, Season 11 (7th Place)
6. Chynna Phillips, Season 13 (9th Place)
7. Susan Lucci, Season 7 (6th Place)
8. Sara Evans, Season 3 (6th Place)
9. Leeza Gibbson, Season 4 (9th Place)
10. Kathy Ireland, Season 9 (14th Place)
11. Martina Navratilova, Season 14 (12th Place)
12. Wendy Williams, Season 12 (10th Place)
13. Kate Gosselin, Season 10 (8th Place)

Tristan MacManus
1. Nancy Grace, Season 13 (5th Place)
2. Gladys Knight, Season 14 (8th Place)
3. Pamela Anderson, Season 15 (12th Place)

Cheryl Burke
1. Drew Lachey, Season 2 (1st Place)
2. Gilles Marini, Season 8 (2nd Place)
3. Emmitt Smith, Season 3 & 15th (1st & 4th Place)
4. Cristian de la Fuente, Season 6 (3rd Place)
5. Ian Ziering, Season 4 (4th Place)
6. Maurice Green, Season 7 (5th Place)
7. Wayne Newton, Season 5 (10th Place)
8. Rick Fox, Season 11 (6th Place)
9. Chris Jericho, Season 12 (7th Place)
10. Tom Delay, Season 9 (13th Place)
11. Chad Ochocinco, Season 10 (4th Place)
12. Rob Kardashian, Season 13 (2nd Place)
13. William Levy, Season 14 (3rd Place)
*I ranked Rob and William last because I could not stand those seasons with Cheryl; she got really lazy with her choreography and both partners went a lot further than they should've based on the fact that the judges slobbered over both.

Valentin Chmerkosvskiy
1. Kelly Monaco, Season 15 (3rd Place)
2. Sherri Shepherd, Season 14 (10th Place)
3. Elisabetta Canalis, Season 13 (11th Place)


Mark Ballas
1. Kristi Yamaguchi, Season 6 (1st Place)
2. Sabrina Bryan, Season 5 (7th Place)
3. Shawn Johnson, Season 8 (1st Place)
4. Katherine Jenkins, Season 14 (2nd Place)
5. Chelsea Kane, Season 12 (3rd Place)
6. Kristin Cavallari, Season 13 (10th Place)
7. Melissa Joan Hart, Season 9 (9th Place)
8. Shannen Doherty, Season 10 (11th Place)
9. Bristol Palin, Season 11 & 15 (3rd & 9th)
10. Kim Kardasian, Season 7 (11th place)
*You initially forgot Kim Kardashian (it's ok, we forgive you), plus 1-5 for me, are really close, I loved all 5 on a somewhat equal level.

Kym Johnson
1. Joey Fatone, Season 4 & 15 (2nd & 12th Place)
2. Warren Sapp, Season 7 (2nd Place)
3. Jerry Springer, Season 3 (5th Place)
4. Hines Ward, Season 12 (1st Place)
5. Mark Cuban, Season 5 (8th Place)
6. David Arquette, Season 13 (6th Place)
7. David Alan Grier, Season 8 (9th Place)
8. Donny Osmond, Season 9 (1st Place)
9. David Hasslehoff, Season 11 (12th Place)
10. Penn Jillette, Season 6 (12th Place)
11. Jaleel White, Season 14 (7th Place)

[Try Again]

thanks PBGamer, I added Kim to the list lol. Below are my rankings:


Derek Hough
1. Shawn Johnson
2. Nicole Scherzinger
3. Jennifer Grey
4. Lil' Kim
5. Brooke Burke
6. Maria Menounous
7. Ricki Lake
8. Jennie Garth
9. Joanna Krupa (I could not stand her)
10. Shannon Elizabeth

Karina Smirnoff
1. Mario Lopez
2. J.R. Martinez
3. Apolo Anton Oho
4. Mario
5. Aaron Carter
6. Gavin DeGraw
7. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
8. Billy Ray Cyrus
9. Mike Sorrentino
10. Rocco DisSpirito
11. Steve Wozinak

Peta Murgatroyd
1. Donald Glover
2. Gilles Marini
3. Ron Artest


Tony Dovolani
1. Stacy Kiebler
2. Melissa Rycroft
3. Jane Seymour
4. Audrina Patridge
5. Marissa Jaret Winoukur
6. Chynna Phillips
7. Sara Evans
8. Susan Lucci
****Big GAP****
9. Leeza Gibson
10. Martina Navratilova
11. Kathy Ireland
12. Wendy Williams
13. Kate Gosselin

Tristan MacManus
1. Gladys Knight
2. Nancy Grace
3. Pamela Anderson


Cheryl Burke
1. Gilles Marini
2. Drew Lachey
3. Emmitt Smith
4. Cristian de la Fuente
5. William Levy
6. Ian Ziering
7. Rick Fox
8. Maurice Greene
9. Rob Kardashian
10. Chad Ochocinco
11. Chris Jericho
12. Wayne Newton
13. Tom Delay

Valentin Chmerkosvskiy
1. Kelly Monaco
2. Sherri Shepherd
3. Elisabette Canalis

Mark Ballas
1. Kristi Yamaguchi
2. Sabrina Bryan
3. Shawn Johnson
4. Katherine Jenkins
5. Chelsea Kane
6. Kristin Cavaliri
7. Melissa Joan Hart
8. Shannen Doherty
9. Bristol Palin
10. Kim Kardashian

Kym Johnson
1. Joey Fatone
2. Hines Ward
3. Warren Sapp
4. Donny Osmond
5. Jaleel White
6. David Alan Grier
7. David Arquette
8. Jerry Springer
9. Mark Cuban
10. David Hasslehoff
11. Penn Jillette

[TruBrit]

Derek Hough
1. Nicole Scherzinger
2. Lil' Kim
3. Shawn Johnson
4. Jennifer Grey
5. Brooke Burke
6. Shannon Elizabeth
7. Jennie Garth
8. Ricki Lake
9. Joanna Krupa
10.Maria Menounous

Karina Smirnoff
1. Mario Lopez
2. J.R. Martinez
3. Apolo Anton Oho
4. Mario
5. Gavin DeGraw
6. Aaron Carter
7. Billy Ray Cyrus
8. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
9. Mike Sorrentino
10. Rocco DisSpirito
11. Steve Wozinak

Tony Dovolani
1. Kate Gosselin
2. Stacy Kiebler
2. Melissa Rycroft
4. Audrina Patridge
5. Marissa Jaret Winoukur
6. Chynna Phillips
7. Sara Evans
8. Susan Lucci
9. Jane Seymour
10. Martina Navratilova
11. Kathy Ireland
12. Wendy Williams
13. Leeza Gibson

Cheryl Burke
1. Drew Lachey
2. Gilles Marini
3. Emmitt Smith
4. William Levy
5. Rob Kardashian
6. Cristian de la Fuente
7. Chad Ochocinco
8. Maurice Greene
9. Ian Ziering
10. Rick Fox
11. Chris Jericho
12. Wayne Newton
13. Tom Delay

Mark Ballas
1. Shawn Johnson
2. Kristi Yamaguchi
3. Sabrina Bryan
4. Katherine Jenkins
5. Chelsea Kane
6. Kristin Cavaliri
7. Melissa Joan Hart
8. Shannen Doherty
9. Bristol Palin
10. Kim Kardashian

Kym Johnson
1. Joey Fatone
2. Hines Ward
3. Warren Sapp
4. Donny Osmond
5. Jaleel White
6. David Arquette
7. Mark Cuban
8. Jerry Springer
9. David Alan Grier
10. David Hasslehoff
11. Penn Jillette


Tristan MacManus
1. Gladys Knight
2. Nancy Grace
3. Pamela Anderson

Peta Murgatroyd
1. Donald Driver
2. Gilles Marini
3. Ron Artest

Valentin Chmerkosvskiy

1. Kelly Monaco
2. Sherri Shepherd
3. Elisabette Canalis

Edited by TruBrit, Mar 11, 2013 @ 2:23 PM.

[Serendi]

Somewhere along the way, Donald Driver has become Donald Glover. I kinda like the idea of Donald Glover doing the show, actually.

ETA: Drat. Danny Glover.

Oh well.

Edited by Serendi, Mar 11, 2013 @ 4:57 PM.

[TruBrit]

Ah, the magic of copy and paste.

[Linds911]

~I ranked mine on how well I enjoyed the partnership, dancing, choreography,& overall season~

Derek Hough
1. Shawn Johnson
2. Jennie Garth
3. Shannon Elizabeth
4. Maria Menounos
5. Brooke Burke
6. Nicole Scherzinger
7. Ricki Lake
8. Jennifer Grey
9. Lil' Kim
10. Joanna Krupa

Karina Smirnoff
1. J.R. Martinez
2. Apolo Anton Ohno
3. Mario Lopez
4. Gavin Degraw
5. Mario
6. Rocco DisSpierto
7. Aaron Carter
8. Floyd Mayweather
9. Billy Ray Cryrus
10. Mike Sorrentino
11. Steve Wozinak

Peta Murgatroyd
1. Donald Driver
2. Gilles Marini
3. Ron Artest


Tony Dovolani
1. Melissa Rycroft
2. Stacy Kiebler
3. Jane Seymour
4. Chynna Phillps
5. Marissa Jaret Winoukur
6. Audrina Patridge
7. Sara Evans
8. Susan Lucci
9. Leeza Gibson
10. Kathy Ireland
11. Wendy Willams
12. Martina Navratilova
13. Kate Gosselin

**7-13 were just not good dancers so I put them as how much I remembered**

Tristan MacManus
1. Gladys Knight
2. Pamela Anderson
3. Nancy Grace

Cheryl Burke
1. Drew Lachey
2. Emmitt Smith
3. Christian de la Fuente
4. Gilles Marini
5. William Levy
6. Rob Kardashian
7. Ian Ziering
8. Chad Ochocino
9. Maurice Green
10. Chris Jericho
11. Rick Fox
12. Wayne Newton
13. Tom Delay

Valentin Chmerkosvskiy
1. Kelly Monaco
2. Sherri Shepherd
3. Elisabeta Canalis

Mark Ballas
1. Sabrina Bryan
2. Shawn Johnson
3. Chelsea Kane
4. Katherine Jenkins
5. Kristi Yamaguchi
6. Kristin Cavalleri
7. Melissa Joan Hart
8. Shannon Doherty
9. Bristol Palin
10. Kim Kardashian

Kym Johnson
1. Joey Fatone
2. Hines Ward
3. Warren Sapp
4. Mark Cuban
5. David Arquette
6. Donny Osmond
7. Jerry Springer
8. David Alan Grier
9. Jaleel White
10. David Hasslehoff
11. Penn Jillette


Should we do one for the other recent(not returning this season)pros? Maks, Chelsie, Lacey, Anna,e.tc? Might be fun as well.

Edited by Linds911, Mar 11, 2013 @ 6:56 PM.

[Try Again]

@Linds911 I was thinking of doing that, but I figured to focus on those who are featured this upcoming season. I want to do a tally by the end of the week and see which stars came out on top.

[QueenL]

Derek Hough
1. Nicole Scherzinger
2. Jennifer Grey
3. Shawn Johnson
4. Brooke Burke
5. Lil' Kim
6. Joanna Krupa
7. Ricki Lake
8. Maria Menounos
9. Jennie Garth
10. Shannon Elizabeth


Karina Smirnoff
1. Mario Lopez
2. Apolo Anton Ohno
3. Aaron Carter
4. Mario 2.0.
5. JR Martinez
6. Billy Ray Cyrus
7. Rocco DisSpireto
8. Gavin DeGraw
9. Floyd Mayweather
10. Mike "The Situation"
11. Steve Wozianck


Peta Murgatroyd
1. Gilles Marini
2. Donald Driver
3. Ron Artest


Tony Dovolani
1. Stacy Keibler
2. Melissa Rycroft

*Wow, I really could care less about any of the rest*

3. Marissa Jaret Winoukur
4. Chynna Phillips
5. Leeza Gibons
6. Sara Evans
7. Audrina Patridge
8. Jane Seymour
8. Susan Lucci
10. Wendy Williams
11. Kate Gosselin
12. Kathy Ireland
13. Martina Navratilova


Tristan MacManus
1. Gladys Knight
2. Nancy Grace
3. Pamela Anderson


Cheryl Burke
1. Gilles Marini
2. Christian de la Fuente
3. Maurice Green
4. Drew Lachey
5. William Levy
6. Emmitt Smith
7. Rick Fox
8. Chris Jericho
9. Ian Ziering
10. Rob Kardashian
11. Chad Ochocinco
12. Tom Delay
13. Wayne Newton


Valentin Chmerkosvskiy
1. Kelly Monac
2. Elisabeta Canalis
3. Sherri Shepard


Mark Ballas
1. Kristi Yamaguchi
2. Chelsea Kane
3. Sabrina Bryan
4. Shawn Johnson
5. Katherine Jenkins
6. Kristin Cavalleri
7. Bristol Palin
8. Melissa Joan Hart
9. Shannon Doherty
10. Kim Kardashian


Kym Johnson
1. Joey Fatone
2. Donny Osmond
3. Jaleel White
4. Warren Sapp
5. Hines Ward
6. Jerry Springer
7. David Allen Grier
8. Mark Cuban
9. David Arquette
10. David Hasslehoff
11. Penn Jillette

[jackiecat]

You all are forgetting Karina and Ralph Macchio