47 replies to this topic

[Try Again]

Hey Everyone,

In our continuation leading up to All-Star season, here's another elimination game to determine our favorite DWTS Champion. We crowned Brooke Burke as our favorite 1st place finisher and Mel B. as our favorite 2nd place star Now it's time to pick our favorite 3rd place star:

Round 1: Week one Dances, Please rank your favorite week 1 performances from Favorite to Least Favorite. The TWO stars with the lowest scores WILL BE ELIMINATED. Please vote base on the dancing. 1st= 20 points, 2nd= 18 points, 3rd= 16 points, 4th= 14 points, 5th= 12 points, 6th= 10 points, 7th= 9 points, 8th= 8 points, 9th= 7 points, 10th= 6 points, 11th= 5 points, 12th= 4points, 13th= 3points, 14th= 2 points


1. Joey McIntrye, Cha-Cha (20): Joey's week 1 Dance
2. Stacy Kiebler, Waltz (22): Stacy's Week 1 Dance
3. Joey Lawrence, Cha-Cha (21): Joey's Week 1 Dance
4. Laila Ali, Foxtrot (22): Lalia's Week 1 Dance
5. Marie Osmond, Foxtrot (21): Marie's Week 1 Dance
6. Cristian de la Fuente, Cha-Cha (21): Cristian's Week 1 Dance
7. Lance Bass, Cha-Cha (22): Lance Week 1 Dance
8. Melissa Rycroft, Waltz (23): Melissa's Week 1 Dance
9. Kelly Osbourne, Viennese Waltz (23): Kelly's Week 1 Dance
10. Erin Andrews, Cha-Cha (21): Erin Andrews' Week 1
11. Bristol Palin, Cha-Cha (18): Bristol's Week 1 Dance
12. Chelsea Kane, Foxtrot (21): Chelsea's Week 1 Dance
13. Ricki Lake, Viennese Waltz (20): Ricki's Week 1 Dance
14. William Levy, Cha-Cha (24): William's Week 1 Dance

[PBGamer89]

1. Melissa Rycroft
2. Stacy Keibler
3. Chelsea Kane
4. Laila Ali
5. Kelly Osbourne
6. Erin Andrews
7. Ricki Lake
8. William Levy
9. Marie Osmond
10. Lance Bass
11. Joey McIntyre
12. Bristol Palin
13. Cristian de la Fuente
14. Joey Lawrence

[Try Again]

Here's my rankings:

1. Laila Ali
2. Stacy Keibler (a little slow for my taste, but impressive)
3. Kelly Osbourne (Pleasant surprise)
4. Melissa Rycroft (Wow to be that good, with the small time of practice she did well)
5. Lance Bass
6. Chelsea Kane
7. William Levy
8. Erin Andrews
9. Ricki Lake
10. Marie Osmond (not bad as I thought it was when her season aired)
11. Cristian de la Fuente
12. Joey Lawrence
13. Bristol Palin (She was alright a little bit stiff)
14. Joey McIntrye

[oakgal]

• Melissa
• Kelly
• William
• Laila
• Stacey
• Lance
• Joey Mac.
• Erin
• Cristian
• Marie
• Chelsea
• Ricki
• Bristol
• Joey "Woah" L.

[Try Again]

Results

Eliminated Stars
13th: Bristol Palin
14th: Joey Lawrence


Top Scoring Stars
Round 1: Melissa Rycroft


Round 2: Week two Dances, Please rank your favorite week 1 performances from Favorite to Least Favorite. The STAR with the lowest scores WILL BE ELIMINATED. Please vote base on the dancing. 1st= 20 points, 2nd= 18 points, 3rd= 16 points, 4th= 14 points, 5th= 12 points, 6th= 10 points, 7th= 9 points, 8th= 8 points, 9th= 7 points, 10th= 6 points, 11th= 5 points, 12th= 4points


1. Melissa Rycroft, Salsa (26): Melissa's Week 2 Dance
2. Stacy Keibler, Rumba (29): Stacy's Week 2 Dance
3. Laila Ali, Mambo (27): Laila's Week 2 Dance
4. Kelly Osbourne, Tango (19): Kelly's Week 2 Dance
5. William Levy, Quickstep (25): William's Week 2 Dance
6. Chelsea Kane, Jive (18): Chelsea's Week 2 Dance
7. Lance Bass, Paso Doble (20): Lance's Week 2 Dance
8. Erin Andrews, Foxtrot (23): Erin's Week 2 Dance
9. Ricki Lake, Jive (23): Ricki's Week 2 Dance
10. Marie Osmond, Mambo (24): Marie's Week 2 Dance
11. Joey McIntrye, Quickstep (21): Joey's Week 2 Dance
12. Cristian de la Fuente, Quickstep (20): Cristian's Week 2 Dance

[PBGamer89]

1. Stacy Keibler
2. Melissa Rycroft
3. Laila Ali
4. Chelsea Kane (Always thought it was very entertaining)
5. William Levy
6. Erin Andrews
7. Ricki Lake
8. Marie Osmond
9. Joey McIntyre
10. Kelly Osbourne (kills me to place her so low, but it was a disappointing Tango)
11. Cristian de la Fuente
12. Lance Bass (just all wrong for a Paso)

[Try Again]

My Rankings:

1. Stacy (Very sexy and sensual)
2. Laila
3. Melissa
4. William
5. Erin
6. Chelsea
7. Ricki
8. Lance (Interesting dance to say the least)
9. Cristian de la Fuente
10. Joey McIntrye
11. Marie
12. Kelly

[oakgal]

• Melissa
• Laila
• Erin
• William
• Stacey
• Marie
• Joey
• Cristian
• Kelly
• Chelsea
• Ricki
• Lance

[Try Again]

Results

Eliminated Contestants
12th: Lance Bass
13th: Bristol Palin
14th: Joey Lawrence

Top Scorers
Round 1: Melissa Rycroft
Round 2: Melissa Rycroft


Round 3: Week three Dances, Please rank your favorite week 1 performances from Favorite to Least Favorite. The STAR with the lowest scores WILL BE ELIMINATED. Please vote base on the dancing. 1st= 20 points, 2nd= 18 points, 3rd= 16 points, 4th= 14 points, 5th= 12 points, 6th= 10 points, 7th= 9 points, 8th= 8 points, 9th= 7 points, 10th= 6 points, 11th= 5 points

1. Melissa Rycroft, Foxtrot (27): Melissa's Week 3 Dance
2. Stacy Kiebler, Tango (27): Stacy's Week 3 Dance
3. Laila Ali, Tango (21): Lalia's Week 3 Dance
4. William Levy, Salsa (28): William's Week 3 Dance
5. Erin Andrews, Waltz (23): Erin's Week 3 Dance
6. Chelsea Kane, Cha-Cha (23): Chelsea's Week 3 Dance
7. Marie Osmond, Tango (26): Marie's Week 3 Dance
8. Ricki Lake, Rumba (27): Ricki's Week 3 Dance
9. Joey McIntrye, Jive (22): Joey's Week 3 Dance
10. Cristian de la Fuente, Jive (25): Cristian's Week 3 Dance
11. Kelly Osbourne, Samba (20): Kelly's Week 3 Dance

[PBGamer89]

1. Melissa Rycroft
2. Ricki Lake
3. Chelsea Kane
4. Stacy Keibler
5. Erin Andrews
6. William Levy
7. Laila Ali
8. Kelly Osbourne
9. Marie Osmond
10. Cristian de la Fuente
11. Joey McIntyre

[Try Again]

My Rankings

1. William Levy (Fun lively dance)
2. Melissa Rycroft
3. Stacy Keibler
4. Ricki Lake
5. Chelsea Kane (Cute little cha-cha)
6. Laila Ali (Solid performance, not one of my favorite by Laila)
7. Erin Andrews (Was indifferent with this performance).
8. Cristian de la Fuente
9. Marie Osmond
10. Kelly Osbourne (I think her earlier dances, minus the first week were her weakest. Hence why I had to rank her so low).
11. Joey McIntrye (Next the best jive, but his jive to "I'm Still Standing" was on a Nicole/Mya/Kristi level compared to Kate Gosselin's version lol).

Edited by Try Again, Jul 18, 2012 @ 6:20 PM.

[oakgal]

• Erin
• William
• Melissa
• Laila
• Cristian
• Stacey
• Chelsea
• Marie
• Kelly
• Joey
• Ricki -HATED IT

[Try Again]

Results

Eliminated Stars
11th= Joey McIntrye
12th= Lance Bass
13th= Bristol Palin
14th= Joey Lawrence


Top Scorers
Week 1= Melissa Rycroft
Week 2= Melissa Rycroft
Week 3= Melissa Rycroft


Round 4: Week four Dances, Please rank your favorite week 1 performances from Favorite to Least Favorite. The STAR with the lowest scores WILL BE ELIMINATED. Please vote base on the dancing. 1st= 20 points, 2nd= 18 points, 3rd= 16 points, 4th= 14 points, 5th= 12 points, 6th= 10 points, 7th= 9 points, 8th= 8 points, 9th= 7 points, 10th= 6 points

1. Melissa Rycroft, Lindy Hop (29): Melissa's Week 4 Dance
2. William Levy, Jive (22): William's Week 4 Dance
3. Erin Andrews, Tango (19.5 average of the Technical & Performance): Erin's Week 4 Dance
4. Stacy Kiebler, Foxtrot (26): Stacy's Week 4 Dance
5. Ricki Lake, Tango (29): Ricki's Week 4 Dance
6. Chelsea Kane, Viennese Waltz (26): Chelsea's Week 4 Dance
7. Laila Ali, Paso Doble (21): Laila's Week 4 Dance
8. Cristian de la Fuente, Paso Doble (26): Cristian's Week 4 Dance
9. Marie Osmond, Viennese Waltz (26): Marie's Week 4 Dance
10. Kelly Osbourne, Charleston (23): Kelly's Week 4 Dance

[dzidas]

Oops, late to the party, but just in time for my favorite routine ever on DWTS!

1. Ricki
2. Stacy
3. Kelly
4. Laila
5. Erin
6. Melissa
7. Marie
8. Cristian
9. Chelsea
10. William

[PBGamer89]

1. Ricki
2. Chelsea
3. Melissa
4. Stacy
5. Kelly
6. Laila
7. Erin
8. Marie
9. Cristian
10. William (a 22 for that?!?)

[Try Again]

My Rankings:

1. Ricki Lake (Her best performance!!!!)
2. Melissa
3. Chelsea
4. Stacy
5. Cristian
6. Kelly
7. Marie (Solid performance)
8. Laila (not the best song choice for that dance)
9. Erin
10. William

[oakgal]

• Melissa
• Cristian
• Kelly
• Laila
• Marie
• Stacey
• Chelsea
• William
• Erin
• Ricki

[Try Again]

Results:

Eliminated Stars
10th= William Levy
11th= Joey McIntrye
12th= Lance Bass
13th= Bristol Palin
14th= Joey Lawrence

Top Scorers
Round 1= Melissa Rycroft
Round 2= Melissa Rycroft
Round 3= Melissa Rycroft
Roud 4= Ricki Lake


Round 5: Week five Dances, Please rank your favorite week 1 performances from Favorite to Least Favorite. The STAR with the lowest scores WILL BE ELIMINATED. Please vote base on the dancing. 1st= 20 points, 2nd= 18 points, 3rd= 16 points, 4th= 14 points, 5th= 12 points, 6th= 10 points, 7th= 9 points, 8th= 8 points, 9th= 7 points

1. Ricki Lake, Foxtrot (24): Ricki's Week 5 Dance
2. Melissa Rycroft, Paso Doble (25): Melissa' s Week 5 Dance
3. Stacy Keibler, Samba (30): Stacy's Week 5 Dance
4. Kelly Osbourne, Paso Doble (24): Kelly's Week 5 Dance
5. Chelsea Kane,Samba (26): Chelsea's Week 5 Dance
6. Laila Ali, Rumba (28): Laila's Week 5 Dance
7. Cristian de la Fuente, Rumba (23): Cristian's Week 5 Dance
8. Marie Osmond, Samba (21): Marie's Week 5 Dance
9. Erin Andrews, Jive (22): Erin's Week 5 Dance

[PBGamer89]

1. Stacy Keibler
2. Chelsea Kane
3. Laila Ali
4. Melissa Rycroft
5. Ricki Lake
6. Kelly Osbourne
7. Erin Andrews
8. Cristian de la Fuente
9. Marie Osmond

[oakgal]

• Laila -- love!
• Stacey
• Kelly
• Melissa
• Cristian
• Chelsea
• Erin
• Marie
• Ricki

[Try Again]

My Rankings

1. Stacy Keibler (My favorite dance by her)
2. Laila
3. Chelsea Kane
4. Melissa Rycroft
5. Ricki Lake
6. Kelly Osbourne
7. Erin Andrews
8. Cristian de la Fuente
9. Marie Osmond

[dzidas]

1. Stacy
2. Melissa
3. Chelsea
4. Ricki
5. Laila
6. Erin
7. Marie
8. Cristian
9. Kelly

[Try Again]

Results

Eliminated Stars
9th= Marie Osmond
10th= William Levy
11th= Joey McIntrye
12th= Lance Bass
13th= Bristol Palin
14th= Joey Lawrence

Top Scorers
Round 1= Melissa Rycroft
Round 2= Melissa Rycroft
Round 3= Melissa Rycroft
Roud 4= Ricki Lake
Round 5= Stacy Keibler


Round 6 [DOUBLE ELIMINATION]: Week six Dances, Please rank your favorite week 6 performances from Favorite to Least Favorite. The TWO STARS with the lowest scores WILL BE ELIMINATED. Please vote base on the dancing. 1st= 20 points, 2nd= 18 points, 3rd= 16 points, 4th= 14 points, 5th= 12 points, 6th= 10 points, 7th= 9 points, 8th= 8 points

1. Stacy Keibler, Jive (30): Stacy's Week 6 Dance
2. Laila Ali, Cha-Cha (28): Laila's Week 6 Dance
3. Chelsea Kane, Quickstep (28): Chelsea's Week 6
4. Melissa Rycroft, Rumba (27): Melissa's Week 6 Dance
5. Ricki Lake, Quickstep (29): Ricki Lake's Week 6 Dance
6. Kelly Osbourne, Jitterbug (20): Kelly's Week 6 Dance
7. Erin Andrews, Samba (25): Erin's Week 6 Dance
8. Cristian de la Fuente, Foxtrot (27): Cristian's Week 6 Dance

[PBGamer89]

1. Stacy Keibler
2. Chelsea Kane
3. Ricki Lake
4. Melissa Rycroft
5. Erin Andrews
6. Laila Ali
7. Kelly Osbourne
8. Cristian de la Fuente

[Try Again]

My Rankings

1. Stacy
2. Ricki
3. Chelsea
4. Laila
5. Erin
6. Cristian
7. Melissa
8. Kelly (She had fun, but I had to rank it so low due to tough competition).

[oakgal]

• Laila
• Cristian
• Stacey
• Erin
• Melissa
• Kelly
• Chelsea
• Ricki -- she is the worst. Cannot believe she's still around.

[dzidas]

1. Ricki (Not the worst... by far)
2. Stacy
3. Melissa
4. Laila
5. Erin
6. Chelsea
7. Kelly
8. Cristian

[Try Again]

Results

Eliminated Stars
7th= Cristian de la Fuente
8th= Kelly Osbourne
9th= Marie Osmond
10th= William Levy
11th= Joey McIntrye
12th= Lance Bass
13th= Bristol Palin
14th= Joey Lawrence

Top Scorers
Round 1= Melissa Rycroft
Round 2= Melissa Rycroft
Round 3= Melissa Rycroft
Roud 4= Ricki Lake
Round 5= Stacy Keibler
Round 6= Stacy Keibler



Round 7: Week seven Dances, Please rank your favorite week 7 performances from Favorite to Least Favorite. The STAR with the lowest scores WILL BE ELIMINATED. Please vote base on the dancing. 1st= 20 points, 2nd= 18 points, 3rd= 16 points, 4th= 14 points, 5th= 12 points, 6th= 10 points


1. Stacy Keibler, Quickstep (27) [I went with her first dance for that week]: Stacy's Week 7 Dance
2. Ricki Lake, Paso Doble (27): Ricki's Week 7 Dance
3. Laila Ali, Samba (30) [I went with her highest score for that week]: Laila's Week 7 Dance
4. Chelsea Kane, Paso Doble (26): Chelsea's Week 7 Dance
5. Melissa Rycroft, Argentine Tango (29): Melissa's Week 7 Dance
6. Erin Andrews, Quickstep (27): Erin's Week 7 Dance

Edited by Try Again, Jul 22, 2012 @ 1:05 PM.

[PBGamer89]

1. Melissa Rycroft
2. Chelsea Kane
3. Ricki Lake
4. Stacy Keibler
5. Laila Ali
6. Erin Andrews

[oakgal]

• Laila
• Erin
• Chelsea
• Stacey
• Melissa
• Ricki -- yup, the worst. By far.