48 replies to this topic

[Try Again]

Hey Everyone,

In our continuation leading up to All-Star season, here's another elimination game to determine our favorite DWTS Champion. We crowned Brooke Burke as our favorite 1st place finisher. Now it's time to pick our favorite Runner-Up:

Round 1: Week one Dances, Please rank your favorite week 1 performances from Favorite to Least Favorite. The TWO stars with the lowest scores WILL BE ELIMINATED. Please vote base on the dancing. 1st= 20 points, 2nd= 18 points, 3rd= 16 points, 4th= 14 points, 5th= 12 points, 6th= 10 points, 7th= 9 points, 8th= 8 points, 9th= 7 points, 10th= 6 points, 11th= 5 points, 12th= 4points, 13th= 3points, 14th= 2 points

1. John O' Hurley, Cha-Cha (20): John's Week 1 Dance
2. Mel B., Cha-Cha (24): Mel's Week 1 Dance
3. Mya, Viennese Waltz (21): Mya's Week 1 Dance
4. Gilles Marini, Cha-Cha (24): Gilles' Week 1 Dance
5. Katherine Jenkins, Foxtrot (26): Kaherine's Week 1
6. Jerry Rice, Cha-Cha (21): Jerry's Week 1 Dance
7. Mario Lopez, Cha-Cha (26): Mario's Week 1 Dance
8. Evan Lysacek, Viennese Waltz (23): Evan's Week 1 Dance
9. Warren Sapp, Cha-Cha (21): Warren's Week 1 Dance
10. Joey Fatone, Cha-Cha (24): Joey's Week 1 Dance
11. Jason Taylor, Foxtrot (22): Jason's Week 1 Dance
12. Kyle Massey, Cha-Cha (23): Kyle's Week 1 Dance
13. Rob Kardashian, Viennese Waltz (16): Rob's Week 1 Dance
14. Kirstie Alley, Cha-Cha (23): Kirstie's Week 1 Dance

Side Note: This is going to be tough competition for me.

[oakgal]

• Gilles
• Mel B
• Evan
• Kirstie
• Katherine
• Mya
• Joey
• Kyle
• Mario
• Jason
• Warren
• Jerry
• John
• Rob

[PBGamer89]

1. Katherine Jenkins
2. Mel B
3. Mya
4. Kirstie Alley
5. Mario Lopez
6. Kyle Massey
7. Gilles Marini
8. Joey Fatone
9. Jason Taylor
10. Warren Sapp
11. Jerry Rice
12. Evan Lysacek
13. John O Hurley
14. Rob Kardashian

[PBGamer89]

edit: Double post

Edited by PBGamer89, Jul 7, 2012 @ 1:06 PM.

[Try Again]

My Rankings
1. Katherine Jenkins
2. Mya
3. Mel B.
4. Mario Lopez
5. Joey Fatone
6. Kyle Massey
7. Gilles Marini
8. Kirstie Alley (She shocked me with this opening performance. I thought she would be a hot mess).
8. Evan Lysacek
9. Jason Taylor
10. Warren Sapp
11. John O'Hurley (One of the more slower cha-cha's ever).
12. Jerry Rice (He practically stood there the whole time).
13. Rob Kardashian (I'm still shocked that he ended up coming in 2nd place that season. Lol)
__________________________________________________________________________________

Eliminated Stars:
13th: John O'Hurley
14th: Rob Kardashian


Top Scorers
Round 1: Mel B. & Katherine Jenkins (Tie)

Round 2: Week two Dances, Please rank your favorite week 2 performances from Favorite to Least Favorite. The STAR with the lowest scores WILL BE ELIMINATED. Please vote base on the dancing. 1st= 20 points, 2nd= 18 points, 3rd= 16 points, 4th= 14 points, 5th= 12 points, 6th= 10 points, 7th= 9 points, 8th= 8 points, 9th= 7 points, 10th= 6 points, 11th= 5 points, 12th= 4points

1. Katherine Jenkins, Jive (26): (Katherine's Week 2 Dance)
2. Mel B., Quickstep (23): (Mel's Week 2 Dance)
3. Mya, Jive (27): (Mya's Week 2 Dance)
4. Gilles Marini, Quickstep (27): (Gilles' Week 2 Dance)
5. Kirstie Alley, Quickstep (20): (Kirstie's Week 2 Dance)
6. Mario Lopez, Quickstep (21): Mario's Week 2 Dance
7. Joey Fatone, Quickstep (24): (Joey Fatone's Week 2 Dance)
8. Kyle Massey, Quickstep (22): (Kyle's Week 2 Dance)
9. Evan Lysacek, Jive (24): (Evan's Week 2 Dance)
10. Jason Taylor, Mambo (27): (Jason's Week 2 Dance)
11. Warren Sapp, Paso Doble (24): (Warren's Week 2 Dance)
12. Jerry Rice, Quickstep (23): (Jerry's Week 2 Dance)

Edited by Try Again, Jul 7, 2012 @ 2:18 PM.

[PBGamer89]

1. Katherine Jenkins (still one of my favorites Jives ever)
2. Mya (also ranks as one of my favorite Jives)
3. Mel B (Carrie Ann was crazy for that 7! Her posture was great!)
4. Gilles Marini
5. Kirstie Alley
6. Joey Fatone
7. Warren Sapp
8. Evan Lysacek
9. Mario Lopez
10. Kyle Massey
11. Jason Taylor
12. Jerry Rice

[PBGamer89]

edit: Double post again (whats going on?) haha

Edited by PBGamer89, Jul 7, 2012 @ 10:01 PM.

[Try Again]

Here's my rankings:

1. Mya (Great performance from her. Glad that Len's ass wasn't there).
2. Katherine (She killed this damn Jive. She made me believe she would be in the finals after this dance.)
3. Gilles
4. Joey Fatone
5. Mel B.
6. Mario Lopez
7. Jason Taylor
8. Warren Sapp (A Little Sloppy at the end, but pretty entertaining)
9. Kyle Massey
10. Kirstie (Got a little out of breath at the end)
11. Evan (Sorry I just felt it was a little fake to me)
12. Jerry Rice

[oakgal]

• Gilles
• Mel B
• Joey
• Mya
• Jason
• Warren
• Jerry
• Kyle
• Evan
• Kirstie
• Mario
• Katherine

[Try Again]

oakgal you must really hate katherine lol.

Eliminations:
12th: Jerry Rice
13th: John O'Hurley
14th: Rob Kardashian


Top Scorers:
Round 1: Katherine Jenkins & Mel B.
Round 2: Mya


Round 3: Week three Dances, Please rank your favorite week 2 performances from Favorite to Least Favorite. The STAR with the lowest scores WILL BE ELIMINATED. Please vote base on the dancing. 1st= 20 points, 2nd= 18 points, 3rd= 16 points, 4th= 14 points, 5th= 12 points, 6th= 10 points, 7th= 9 points, 8th= 8 points, 9th= 7 points, 10th= 6 points, 11th= 5 points

1. Mya, Rumba (27: Mya's Week 3 Dance
2. Gilles Marini, Samba (27): Gilles' Week 3 Dance
3. Mel B., Jive (27): Mel's Week 3 Dance
4. Katherine Jenkins, Waltz (29): Katherine's Week 3 Dance
5. Joey Fatone, Tango (24): Joey's Week 3 Dance
6. Warren Sapp, Viennese Waltz (25): Warren's Week 3 Dance
7. Jason Taylor, Jive (23): Jason's Week 3 Dance
8. Kirstie Alley, Rumba (21): Kirstie's Week 3
9. Mario Lopez, Tango (22): Mario's Week 3 Dance
10. Kyle Massey, Waltz (23): Kyle's Week 3
11. Evan Lysacek, Quickstep (26): Evan's Week 3 Dance

[PBGamer89]

1. Katherine Jenkins
2. Mya (still one of the steamiest Rumbas ever; loved Bruno fanning himself and Carrie covering her mouth)
3. Mel B (amazing Jive!)
4. Gilles Marini
5. Joey Fatone
6. Kirstie Alley
7. Evan Lysacek
8. Jason Taylor
9. Warren Sapp
10. Kyle Massey
11. Mario Lopez

[legaleagle44]

I should have gotten here sooner -- I will go to my grave maintaining that John O'Hurley was ROBBED!

That having been said:

1. Gilles Marini
2. Evan Lysacek
3. Mya
4. Mel B.
5. Katherine Jenkins
6. Warren Sapp
7. Jason Taylor
8. Kirstie Alley
9. Joey Fatone (Seriously -- Star Wars?)
10. Mario Lopez
11. Kyle Massey

[oakgal]

I was wondering where you were, legaleagle!

• Gilles
• Evan
• Mel B
• Mya
• Warren
• Jason
• Kirstie
• Katherine
• Kyle
• Mario
• Joey

[Try Again]

My Rankings

1. Katherine
2. Mya (One of the more sexiest Rumbas. Wow)
3. Gilles
4. Mel B.
5. Evan
6. Mario Lopez
7. Warren Sapp
8. Joey Fatone
9. Kyle
10. Kirstie Alley (She had great hip action)
11. Jason Taylor (Way too slow for a Jive)

[legaleagle44]

I was wondering where you were, legaleagle!

I decided to take a break from this game -- it's a bit on the repetitious side for me, to be honest. I only voted yesterday because some of my favorite routines (Gilles' Samba and Evan's Quickstep) were featured in this round -- and because I wanted to get the last word in on John O'Hurley!

[Try Again]

Results:

Eliminated Contestants
11th: Kyle Massey
12th: Jerry Rice
13th: John O'Hurley
14th: Rob Kardashian


Top Scorers
Round 1: Katherine Jenkins & Mel B.
Round 2: Mya
Round 3: Gilles Marini


Round 4: Week four Dances, Please rank your favorite week 2 performances from Favorite to Least Favorite. The STAR with the lowest scores WILL BE ELIMINATED. Please vote base on the dancing. 1st= 20 points, 2nd= 18 points, 3rd= 16 points, 4th= 14 points, 5th= 12 points, 6th= 10 points, 7th= 9 points, 8th= 8 points, 9th= 7 points, 10th= 6 points,

1. Gilles Marini, Argentine Tango (30): Gilles' Week 4 Dance
2. Mya, Lambada (28): Mya's Week 4 Dance
3. Mel B., Viennese Waltz (26): Mel's Week 4 Dance
4. Katherine Jenkins, Paso Doble (24): Katherine's Week 4 Dance
5. Evan Lysacek, Tango (26): Evan's Week 4 Dance
6. Warren Sapp, Samba (22): Warren's Week 4 Dance
7. Kirstie Alley, Waltz (22): Kirstie's Week 4 Dance
8. Jason Taylor, Viennese Waltz (29): Jason's Week 4 Dance
9. Joey Fatone, Paso Doble (28): Joey's week 4 Dance
10. Mario Lopez, Paso Doble (29): Mario's Week 4 Dance

[PBGamer89]

1. Mya
2. Mel B
3. Gilles Marini
4. Katherine Jenkins
5. Mario Lopez
6. Joey Fatone
7. Kirstie Alley
8. Evan Lysacek
9. Warren Sapp
10. Jason Taylor (such an obvious mistake shouldn't have gotten 10's)

[legaleagle44]

1. Gilles Marini (because, DUH!)
2. Evan Lysacek
3. Mya
4. Mel B.
5. Katherine Jenkins
6. Warren Sapp
7. Kirstie Alley
8. Jason Taylor
9. Joey Fatone
10. Mario Lopez

Edited by legaleagle44, Jul 9, 2012 @ 4:11 PM.

[oakgal]

• Gilles -- GIANT duh!
• Mya -- my favourite dance of hers. The only true Lambada.
• Evan
• Mel B
• Mario
• Joey
• Kirstie
• Warren
• Katherine
• Jason

[Try Again]

My Rankings

1. Gilles (Killed that performance!!!!, enough said)
2. Mya (Damn another sexy performance!!!!)
3. Mario
4. Joey (I don't remember watching his paso before. Great performance)
5. Mel B.
6. Katherine (solid performance, not my favorite by her)
7. Jason
8. Evan
9. Kirstie
10. Warren (A little sloppy)
____________________________________________________________________________________
Results

Eliminated Stars
10th: Jason Taylor
11th: Kyle Massey
12th: Jerry Rice
13th: John O'Hurley
14th: Rob Kardashian


Top Scorers
Round 1: Mel B. & Katherine Jenkins
Round 2: Mya
Round 3: Gilles
Round 4: Gilles


Round 5: Week five Dances, Please rank your favorite week 2 performances from Favorite to Least Favorite. The STAR with the lowest scores WILL BE ELIMINATED. Please vote base on the dancing. 1st= 20 points, 2nd= 18 points, 3rd= 16 points, 4th= 14 points, 5th= 12 points, 6th= 10 points, 7th= 9 points, 8th= 8 points, 9th= 7 points


1. Gilles, Paso Doble (29): Gilles' Week 5 Dance
2. Mya, Argentine Tango (27): Mya's Week 5 Dance
3. Mel B., Samba (29): Mel's Week 5 Dance
4. Evan, Rumba (27): Evan's Week 5 Dance
5. Mario, Rumba (27): Mario's Week 5 Dance
6. Katherine, Argentine Tango (29): Katherine's Week 5 Dance
7. Joey Fatone, Rumba (25): Joey's Week 5 Dance
8. Kirstie Alley, Foxtrot (23): Kirstie's Week 5 Dance
9. Warren Sapp, Hustle (25): Warren's Week 5 Dance

Edited by Try Again, Jul 10, 2012 @ 10:46 AM.

[PBGamer89]

1. Mel B (that was her breakout week; if she can't Samba to her own song... haha)
2. Katherine (what an amazing Argentine Tango)
3. Mya (technically brilliant, but was a bit distant, agreed with Bruno and CA)
4. Gilles
5. Evan
6. Mario
7. Joey
8. Kirstie
9. Warren

[legaleagle44]

1. Gilles
2. Evan
3. Katherine
4. Mel B
5. Mya
6. Mario
7. Warren
8. Joey
9. Kirstie (No, just -- NO.)

[oakgal]

• Mel B.
• Gilles
• Evan
• Mya
• Joey
• Mario
• Katherine
• Kirstie
• Warren

[Try Again]

My Rankings

1. Mel B. (Fun and flirty performance)
2. Katherine (Loved this performance)
3. Gilles (Another great performance by him)
4. Mya (solid performance, there was a disconnect)
5. Mario
6. Warren (That was a fun performance lol)
7. Joey
8. Evan (Awkward!!!)
9. Kirstie

____________________________________________________________________________________

Eliminated Stars

9th: Kirstie Alley
10th: Jason Taylor
11th: Kyle Massey
12th: Jerry Rice
13th: John O'Hurley
14th: Rob Kardashian


Top Scorers
Round 1: Katherine Jenkins & Mel B.
Round 2: Mya
Round 3: Gilles Marini
Round 4: Gilles Marini
Round 5: Mel B.

Round 6 [Double Elimination]: Week six Dances, Please rank your favorite week six performances from Favorite to Least Favorite. The TWO STARS with the lowest scores WILL BE ELIMINATED. Please vote base on the dancing. 1st= 20 points, 2nd= 18 points, 3rd= 16 points, 4th= 14 points, 5th= 12 points, 6th= 10 points, 7th= 9 points, 8th= 8 points


1. Mel B., Rumba (30): Mel's Week 6 Dance
2. Gilles Marini, Jive (26): Gilles' Week 6 Dance
3. Katherine Jenkins, Samba (29): Katherine's Week 6 Dance
4. Mya, Jitterbug (24): Mya's Week 6 Dance
5. Evan Lysacek, Samba (21): Evan's Week 6 Dance
6. Mario Lopez, Mambo (28): Mario's Week 6 Dance
7. Joey Fatone, Samba (27): Joey's Week 6 Dance
8. Warren Sapp, Rumba (26): Warren's Week 6 Dance

Edited by Try Again, Jul 11, 2012 @ 10:52 AM.

[legaleagle44]

1. Gilles Marini
2. Evan Lysacek
3. Mel B.
4. Katherine Jenkins
5. Mya
6. Mario Lopez
7. Joey Fatone
8. Warren Sapp

[PBGamer89]

1. Mel B
2. Katherine Jenkins
3. Mya
4. Joey Fatone
5. Gilles Marini (Jive wasn't his best)
6. Mario Lopez
7. Evan Lysacek
8. Warren Sapp (he didn't do much)

[oakgal]

• Mel B. -- love this one.
• Gilles
• Evan
• Mya
• Mario
• Joey
• Katherine
• Warren

Edited by oakgal, Jul 12, 2012 @ 2:03 AM.

[Try Again]

Here are my rankings:

1. Mel B. (Hot, Sexy & Steamy)
2. Joey (Fun performance, one of my favorites by Joey)
3. Katherine (Fun dance by Katherine)
4. Mario Lopez (Great performance)
5. Mya (My least favorite of her's by far..)
6. Gilles (Solid performance, not one of my favorites by him)
7. Warren
8. Evan (Meh not that impressed to be honest)

Edited by Try Again, Jul 11, 2012 @ 11:43 PM.

[oakgal]

I watched them again and altered my votes. Heads up! ;)

[Try Again]

Thanks oakgal for the heads up. Well since it's the four us voting let's continue the competition.


Eliminated
7th: Mario Lopez
8th: Warren Sapp
9th: Kirstie Alley
10th: Jason Taylor
11th: Kyle Massey
12th: Jerry Rice
13th: John O'Hurley
14th: Rob Kardashian


Top Scorers
Round 1: Mel B. & Katherine Jenkins
Round 2: Mya
Round 3: Gilles Marini
Round 4: Gilles Marini
Round 5: Mel B.
Round 6: Mel B.



Round 7: Week 7 Dances, Please rank your favorite week six performances from Favorite to Least Favorite. The STAR with the lowest scores WILL BE ELIMINATED. Please vote base on the dancing. 1st= 20 points, 2nd= 18 points, 3rd= 16 points, 4th= 14 points, 5th= 12 points, 6th= 10 points.

[Please Note: Because Mel & Joey's seasons didn't have the team dance, I went with their highest scoring dance for that particular week].

1. Mel B., Paso Doble (30): Mel's Week 7 Dance
2. Gilles Marini, Viennese Waltz (27): Gilles' Week 7 Dance
3. Katherine Jenkins, Rumba (27): Katherine's Week 7 Dance
4. Mya, Foxtrot (25): Mya's Week 7 Dance
5. Evan Lysacek, Argentine Tango (30): Evan's Week 7 Dance
6. Joey Fatone, Jive (30): Joey's Week 7 Performance