I already love Casey's character just from the trailer alone, her birthday party meltdown and picking a fight with the younger girl at the gym were great parts they included in the trailer.
Casey Wilson has always annoyed the hell out of me, and I for one was hoping that when Casey came back to "physically fight" the younger girl at the gym (as opposed to what, mentally fight her?), that the younger girl kicked her wideload of an ass.
I'm not sure what they did to Eliza Coupe, but her character is basically stripped of everything that makes her such an interesting actress to watch. She is too good to be playing the umpteenth version of the married perfectionist. Get her back on Community playing Abed's soulmate, STAT!
While I accept that Elisha Cuthbert is simply not a good actress, I still am a fan of hers, and even she deserves better than the thinly written character she's been given.
Damon Wayans Jr, on the other hand, is this shows saving grace. Hopefully he is cast in a good sitcom after this show gets canceled.
The other two dudes are just interchangeable and completely forgettable. The only way to tell them apart is that one constantly needs to remind us that he is in fact gay.
If they want to really do something interesting, they could weave a plotline where the other dude slowly realizes why his relationship with Spawn failed. It's because he is gay and has been in love with the chubby bromosexual the whole time. Certainly better than the young Kathy Bates outing every one of Casey Wilson's love interests.