Jump to content

Merlin Survival Game


This topic has been archived. This means that you cannot reply to this topic.

514 replies to this topic

#1

MsTaken

MsTaken

    Stalker

  • Gender:Female

Posted Mar 5, 2011 @ 8:10 PM

It may not be a perfect show by any stretch, but those of us who love Merlin are hopeless to resists its earnest, heartwarming and cheesy charm!

I'm thinking most of you know the rules by now: once per 24 hour period, you can vote for (++) or against (--) three of the items on our list. Once half the list has been eliminated, we change the ++ to + to ensure that the game doesn't last forever.

I'm thinking we can begin this survival game with characters, and then move on to relationships/friendships, episodes etc.
Here's the surprisingly brief character list that imdb and I have come up with. If I've left out semi-significant characters (more than 2 episodes), which is always quite likely, feel free to add them. Happy voting!

15 - Merlin
15 - Arthur
15 - Gwen
15 - Morgana
15 - Uther
15 - Gaius
15 - Lancelot
15 - The Dragon
15 - Mordred
15 - Gwain
15 - Morgause
15 - Sir Leon
15 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
15 - Nimueh
15 - Cenred
15 - Hunith
15 - Ygraine

#2

SueB

SueB

    Stalker

Posted Mar 5, 2011 @ 9:20 PM

++ Merlin
++ Arthur
++ Gwen

17 - Merlin
17 - Arthur
17 - Gwen
15 - Morgana
15 - Uther
15 - Gaius
15 - Lancelot
15 - The Dragon
15 - Mordred
15 - Gwain
15 - Morgause
15 - Sir Leon
15 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
15 - Nimueh
15 - Cenred
15 - Hunith
15 - Ygraine

Edited by SueB, Mar 5, 2011 @ 9:21 PM.


#3

thuganomics85

thuganomics85

    Stalker

Posted Mar 5, 2011 @ 9:46 PM

Yeah, I suspect I'm going to be giving a ton of positive votes in this game.

Merlin ++
Arthur ++
Gwain ++

19 - Merlin
19 - Arthur
17 - Gwen
17 - Gwain
15 - Morgana
15 - Uther
15 - Gaius
15 - Lancelot
15 - The Dragon
15 - Mordred
15 - Morgause
15 - Sir Leon
15 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
15 - Nimueh
15 - Cenred
15 - Hunith
15 - Ygraine

#4

CarsonMcKay

CarsonMcKay

    Fanatic

  • Gender:Female

Posted Mar 5, 2011 @ 10:19 PM

Mordred --
Lancelot ++
Merlin ++

21 - Merlin
19 - Arthur
17 - Lancelot
17 - Gwen
17 - Gwain
15 - Morgana
15 - Uther
15 - Gaius
15 - The Dragon
15 - Morgause
15 - Sir Leon
15 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
15 - Nimueh
15 - Cenred
15 - Hunith
15 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred

#5

Radagast

Radagast

    Fanatic

Posted Mar 5, 2011 @ 10:38 PM

Gaius ++
Sir Leon ++
Geoffrey of Monmouth ++

Gotta give the allies some love!

21 - Merlin
19 - Arthur
17 - Lancelot
17 - Gwen
17 - Gwain
17 - Gaius
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
15 - Morgana
15 - Uther
15 - The Dragon
15 - Morgause
15 - Nimueh
15 - Cenred
15 - Hunith
15 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred

#6

MsTaken

MsTaken

    Stalker

  • Gender:Female

Posted Mar 5, 2011 @ 10:46 PM

I'm glad people are playing!

Merlin ++
Arthur ++
Gaius ++

23 - Merlin
21 - Arthur
19 - Gaius
17 - Lancelot
17 - Gwen
17 - Gwain
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
15 - Morgana
15 - Uther
15 - The Dragon
15 - Morgause
15 - Nimueh
15 - Cenred
15 - Hunith
15 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred

#7

The Mad Maple

The Mad Maple

    Stalker

  • Location:Happy Valley, NL, Canada

Posted Mar 6, 2011 @ 1:45 AM

In honour of "The Eye of the Phoenix" (the episode that aired in Canada this evening)....

The Magic ++
The Courage ++
The Strength ++

25 - Merlin
23 - Arthur
19 - Gwain

19 - Gaius
17 - Lancelot
17 - Gwen
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
15 - Morgana
15 - Uther
15 - The Dragon
15 - Morgause
15 - Nimueh
15 - Cenred
15 - Hunith
15 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred

#8

MsTaken

MsTaken

    Stalker

  • Gender:Female

Posted Mar 6, 2011 @ 9:10 AM

Merlin ++
Arthur ++
Gaius ++

27 - Merlin
25 - Arthur
21 - Gaius
19 - Gwain
17 - Lancelot
17 - Gwen
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
15 - Morgana
15 - Uther
15 - The Dragon
15 - Morgause
15 - Nimueh
15 - Cenred
15 - Hunith
15 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred

#9

thuganomics85

thuganomics85

    Stalker

Posted Mar 6, 2011 @ 10:57 AM

Merlin ++
Arthur ++
Morgana ++ (I'll throw her at least one positive vote.)

29 - Merlin
27 - Arthur
21 - Gaius
19 - Gwain
17 - Lancelot
17 - Gwen
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
17 - Morgana
15 - Uther
15 - The Dragon
15 - Morgause
15 - Nimueh
15 - Cenred
15 - Hunith
15 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred

#10

Incorporal

Incorporal

    Loyal Viewer

Posted Mar 6, 2011 @ 11:31 AM

Arthur ++
Gwen ++
Morgana - -



29 - Merlin
29 - Arthur
21 - Gaius
19 - Gwain
19 - Gwen
17 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
15 - Morgana
15 - Uther
15 - The Dragon
15 - Morgause
15 - Nimueh
15 - Cenred
15 - Hunith
15 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred

#11

NikkiH

NikkiH

    Fanatic

Posted Mar 6, 2011 @ 5:30 PM

Arthur ++
Gwain ++
Morgana --

31 - Arthur
29 - Merlin
21 - Gaius
21 - Gwain
19 - Gwen
17 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
15 - Uther
15 - The Dragon
15 - Morgause
15 - Nimueh
15 - Cenred
15 - Hunith
15 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred
13 - Morgana

#12

SueB

SueB

    Stalker

Posted Mar 6, 2011 @ 11:26 PM

Arthur ++
Merlin ++
Cenred --

33 - Arthur
31 - Merlin

21 - Gaius
21 - Gwain
19 - Gwen
17 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
15 - Uther
15 - The Dragon
15 - Morgause
15 - Nimueh
15 - Hunith
15 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred
13 - Morgana
13 - Cenred

#13

thuganomics85

thuganomics85

    Stalker

Posted Mar 7, 2011 @ 2:04 AM

Arthur ++
Merlin ++
Uther ++

35 - Arthur
33 - Merlin
21 - Gaius
21 - Gwain
19 - Gwen
17 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
17 - Uther
15 - The Dragon
15 - Morgause
15 - Nimueh
15 - Hunith
15 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred
13 - Morgana
13 - Cenred

#14

CarsonMcKay

CarsonMcKay

    Fanatic

  • Gender:Female

Posted Mar 7, 2011 @ 9:16 AM

Lancelot ++
Cenred --
Gwen ++


35 - Arthur
33 - Merlin
21 - Gaius
21 - Gwain
21 - Gwen
19 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
17 - Uther
15 - The Dragon
15 - Morgause
15 - Nimueh
15 - Hunith
15 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred
13 - Morgana
11 - Cenred

#15

MsTaken

MsTaken

    Stalker

  • Gender:Female

Posted Mar 7, 2011 @ 9:18 AM

Top 2 ++
Morgause ++

37 - Arthur
35 - Merlin
21 - Gaius
21 - Gwain
21 - Gwen
19 - Lancelot
17 - Morgause
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
17 - Uther
15 - The Dragon
15 - Nimueh
15 - Hunith
15 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred
13 - Morgana
11 - Cenred

Edited by MsTaken, Mar 7, 2011 @ 9:19 AM.


#16

acatmaylook

acatmaylook

    Fanatic

  • Location:Mid-Missouri, USA
  • Interests:Cats, "personality" dolls (Cher, Elvis, etc.) reading, comedies, reality shows where the contestants DO something more than Survive.

Posted Mar 7, 2011 @ 1:28 PM

(Evil smirky girls)
Morgana --
Morgause --
Nimueh--

37 - Arthur
35 - Merlin
21 - Gaius
21 - Gwain
21 - Gwen
19 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
17 - Uther
15 - The Dragon
15 - Hunith
15 - Ygraine
15 - Morgause
13 - Mordred
13 - Nimueh
11 - Morgana
11 - Cenred

#17

Incorporal

Incorporal

    Loyal Viewer

Posted Mar 7, 2011 @ 1:39 PM

Gwen ++
Ygraine --
Nimueh --

37 - Arthur
35 - Merlin
23 - Gwen
21 - Gaius
21 - Gwain
19 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
17 - Uther
15 - The Dragon
15 - Hunith
15 - Morgause
13 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred
11 - Nimueh
11 - Morgana
11 - Cenred

#18

PhantomChic

PhantomChic

    Stalker

  • Location:Miamisburg, OH

Posted Mar 7, 2011 @ 2:44 PM

Arthur ++
Merlin ++
Uther ++

39 - Arthur
37 - Merlin
23 - Gwen
21 - Gaius
21 - Gwain
19 - Uther
19 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
15 - The Dragon
15 - Hunith
15 - Morgause
13 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred
11 - Nimueh
11 - Morgana
11 - Cenred

#19

NikkiH

NikkiH

    Fanatic

Posted Mar 7, 2011 @ 9:43 PM

Arthur ++
Gaius ++
Morgana --

41 - Arthur
37 - Merlin
23 - Gwen
23 - Gaius
21 - Gwain
19 - Uther
19 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
15 - The Dragon
15 - Hunith
15 - Morgause
13 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred
11 - Nimueh
11 - Cenred
09 - Morgana

#20

thuganomics85

thuganomics85

    Stalker

Posted Mar 8, 2011 @ 3:29 AM

Merlin ++
Gwain ++
The Dragon ++

41 - Arthur
39- Merlin
23 - Gwen
23 - Gaius
23 - Gwain
19 - Uther
19 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
17 - The Dragon
15 - Hunith
15 - Morgause
13 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred
11 - Nimueh
11 - Cenred
09 - Morgana

#21

MsTaken

MsTaken

    Stalker

  • Gender:Female

Posted Mar 8, 2011 @ 9:14 AM

I promised myself I'd give -- today, if only so that the game doesn't last forever!

Merlin ++
Gwen --
Lancelot --

41 - Arthur
41- Merlin
23 - Gaius
23 - Gwain
21 - Gwen
19 - Uther
17 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
17 - The Dragon
15 - Hunith
15 - Morgause
13 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred
11 - Nimueh
11 - Cenred
09 - Morgana

#22

Radagast

Radagast

    Fanatic

Posted Mar 8, 2011 @ 11:28 AM

I gotta give some for the lovely ladies. Evil or not.

Gwen ++
Morgana ++
Nimueh ++

41 - Arthur
41 - Merlin
23 - Gaius
23 - Gwain
23 - Gwen
19 - Uther
17 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
17 - The Dragon
15 - Hunith
15 - Morgause
13 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred
13 - Nimueh
11 - Cenred
11 - Morgana

#23

PhantomChic

PhantomChic

    Stalker

  • Location:Miamisburg, OH

Posted Mar 8, 2011 @ 4:30 PM

Arthur ++
Merlin ++
Uther ++

41 - Arthur
41 - Merlin
23 - Gaius
23 - Gwain
23 - Gwen
19 - Uther
17 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
17 - The Dragon
15 - Hunith
15 - Morgause
13 - Ygraine
13 - Mordred
13 - Nimueh
11 - Cenred
11 - Morgana

#24

Incorporal

Incorporal

    Loyal Viewer

Posted Mar 8, 2011 @ 5:18 PM

Gwen ++
Mordred --
Smirkana --


41 - Arthur
41 - Merlin
25- Gwen
23 - Gaius
23 - Gwain
19 - Uther
17 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
17 - The Dragon
15 - Hunith
15 - Morgause
13 - Ygraine
13 - Nimueh
11 - Cenred
11 - Mordred
09 - Morgana

#25

CarsonMcKay

CarsonMcKay

    Fanatic

  • Gender:Female

Posted Mar 8, 2011 @ 6:56 PM

Bottom 3 --

41 - Arthur
41 - Merlin
25- Gwen
23 - Gaius
23 - Gwain
19 - Uther
17 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
17 - The Dragon
15 - Hunith
15 - Morgause
13 - Ygraine
13 - Nimueh
09 - Cenred
09 - Mordred
07 - Morgana


#26

thuganomics85

thuganomics85

    Stalker

Posted Mar 9, 2011 @ 1:05 AM

Arthur ++
Merlin ++
Morgana ++

43 - Arthur
43 - Merlin
25- Gwen
23 - Gaius
23 - Gwain
19 - Uther
17 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
17 - The Dragon
15 - Hunith
15 - Morgause
13 - Ygraine
13 - Nimueh
09 - Cenred
09 - Mordred
09 - Morgana

#27

MsTaken

MsTaken

    Stalker

  • Gender:Female

Posted Mar 9, 2011 @ 1:17 AM

Top 2 ++
Gwen --

45 - Arthur
45 - Merlin
23- Gwen
23 - Gaius
23 - Gwain
19 - Uther
17 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
17 - The Dragon
15 - Hunith
15 - Morgause
13 - Ygraine
13 - Nimueh
09 - Cenred
09 - Mordred
09 - Morgana

#28

Incorporal

Incorporal

    Loyal Viewer

Posted Mar 9, 2011 @ 1:09 PM

Boring people (Geoffrey, Hunith, Ygraine) - -


45 - Arthur
45 - Merlin
23- Gwen
23 - Gaius
23 - Gwain
19 - Uther
17 - Lancelot
17 - Sir Leon
17 - The Dragon
15 - Morgause
15 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
13 - Hunith
13 - Nimueh
11 - Ygraine
09 - Cenred
09 - Mordred
09 - Morgana

#29

acatmaylook

acatmaylook

    Fanatic

  • Location:Mid-Missouri, USA
  • Interests:Cats, "personality" dolls (Cher, Elvis, etc.) reading, comedies, reality shows where the contestants DO something more than Survive.

Posted Mar 9, 2011 @ 1:23 PM

Sir Leon--
Nimueh--
Hunith--

45 - Arthur
45 - Merlin
23- Gwen
23 - Gaius
23 - Gwain
19 - Uther
17 - Lancelot
17 - The Dragon
15 - Sir Leon
15 - Morgause
15 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
11 - Hunith
11 - Nimueh
11 - Ygraine
09 - Cenred
09 - Mordred
09 - Morgana

#30

NikkiH

NikkiH

    Fanatic

Posted Mar 9, 2011 @ 3:47 PM

Top 2 ++
Morgana --

47 - Arthur
47 - Merlin
23- Gwen
23 - Gaius
23 - Gwain
19 - Uther
17 - Lancelot
17 - The Dragon
15 - Sir Leon
15 - Morgause
15 - Geoffrey of Monmouth
11 - Hunith
11 - Nimueh
11 - Ygraine
09 - Cenred
09 - Mordred
07 - Morgana