1358 replies to this topic

[Sentosa]

Imagine, if needs be, that you are a heterosexual male. Tyra's written off many a contestant for being too sexy, or too "men's mag" in the past, usually to suit her own end. Model potential, personality and prettiness aside, who are the most f**kable contestants of each cycle and who got lumbered unjustifiably with the critique?

You have 3 credits to award or take away each time you vote. You can +++/--- from one contestant, or split them between two or three girls as you see fit.

Starting with cycle 1:

Ebony -
Shannon +
Nicole +

Shannon 16
Nicole 16
Adrienne 15
Elyse 15
Robin 15
Kesse 15
Giselle 15
Katie 15
Tessa 15
Ebony 14

[soBlu]

Katie+
Kesse+
Shannon--

Nicole 16
Katie 16
Kesse 16
Shannon 15
Adrianne 15
Elyse 15
Robin 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Ebony 14

[Oholibamah]

Nicole --
Robin -

Katie 16
Kesse 16
Shannon 15
Adrianne 15
Elyse 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Ebony 14
Robin 14
Nicole 14

[Caycee]

Katie 16
Kesse 16
Shannon 15
Adrianne 15
Elyse 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Ebony 14
Nicole 14
Robin 11

[Frank024]

Katie +
Elyse, Ebony -/-

Katie 17
Kesse 16
Shannon 15
Adrianne 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Nicole 14
Elyse 14
Ebony 13
Robin 11

[ThighraBanks]

Nicole ---(--------------------------------------------------)
I still believe she's a dude.

Katie 17
Kesse 16
Shannon 15
Adrianne 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Elyse 14
Ebony 13
Robin 11
Nicole 11

[Sentosa]

Ebony ---

Katie 17
Kesse 16
Shannon 15
Adrianne 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Elyse 14
Robin 11
Nicole 11
Ebony 10

[mini-mart]

The first post mentionnedr hetero male opinion, but I'll go with my personal girl-who-likes-girls view of sexy:

Elyse ++ (nerdhot!)
Ebony -

Katie 17
Kesse 16
Elyse 16
Shannon 15
Adrianne 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Robin 11
Nicole 11
Ebony 09

[Sentosa]

Adrienne ---

Katie 17
Kesse 16
Elyse 16
Shannon 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Adrianne 12
Robin 11
Nicole 11
Ebony 09

[soBlu]

Shannon's railthin body and leathery face =/= sexy.

Kesse, Adrianne+
Robin-

Katie 17
Kesse 17
Elyse 16
Shannon 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Adrianne 13
Nicole 11
Robin 10
Ebony 09

[mini-mart]

Elyse +
Adri +
Ebony -

Katie 17
Kesse 17
Elyse 17
Shannon 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Adrianne 14
Nicole 11
Robin 10
Ebony 08

[kemmek]

Adri + (Her diamond photo)
Ebony -- (Just her persona in general)

Katie 17
Kesse 17
Elyse 17
Shannon 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Adrianne 15
Nicole 11
Robin 10
Ebony 06

[Sentosa]

Ebony ---

Katie 17
Kesse 17
Elyse 17
Shannon 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Adrianne 15
Nicole 11
Robin 10
Ebony 03

[mini-mart]

Adri ++
Ebony -

Katie 17
Kesse 17
Elyse 17
Adrianne 17
Shannon 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Nicole 11
Robin 10
Ebony 01

[soBlu]

Robin---

Katie 17
Kesse 17
Elyse 17
Adrianne 17
Shannon 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Nicole 11
Robin 07
Ebony 01

[mini-mart]

I like the way you think.
Robin ---

Katie 17
Kesse 17
Elyse 17
Adrianne 17
Shannon 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Nicole 11
Robin 04
Ebony 01

[NewTyrastic]

Nothing's sexier than a girl that constantly reads the Bible and refuses to look or talk to you
Robin --
Adrianne +

Adrianne 18
Katie 17
Kesse 17
Elyse 17
Shannon 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Nicole 11
Robin 02
Ebony 01

Edited by NewTyrastic, Dec 7, 2009 @ 5:41 PM.

[Sentosa]

Ebony -
Adrianne --
While she's obviously gone down the very sexy route since the show, and her diamond shot was hot (though not as good as Elyse's in my opinion) Adrianne was a MESS during her cycle. The two lasting images I have of her are her appearance at casting, and her appearance at the go-sees in Paris. Ick.

Katie 17
Kesse 17
Elyse 17
Adrianne 16
Shannon 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Nicole 11
Robin 02

So Unsexy:
10. Ebony

[mini-mart]

Robin --
Adri +

Katie 17
Kesse 17
Elyse 17
Adrianne 17
Shannon 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Nicole 11

So Unsexy:
09. Robin
10. Ebony

[soBlu]

Kesse+
Shannon, Giselle--

Kesse 18
Katie 17
Elyse 17
Adrianne 17
Tessa 15
Giselle 13
Shannon 13
Nicole 11

So Unsexy:
09. Robin
10. Ebony

[Sentosa]

Kesse -
Shannon +
Elyse +

Elyse 18
Kesse 17
Katie 17
Adrianne 17
Tessa 15
Shannon 14
Giselle 13
Nicole 11

So Unsexy:
09. Robin
10. Ebony

[mini-mart]

Adri ++
Elyse +

Elyse 19
Adrianne 19
Kesse 17
Katie 17
Tessa 15
Shannon 14
Giselle 13
Nicole 11

So Unsexy:
09. Robin
10. Ebony

[Sentosa]

Giselle -
Kesse -
Shannon +

Elyse 19
Adrianne 19
Katie 17
Kesse 16
Tessa 15
Shannon 15
Giselle 12
Nicole 11

So Unsexy:
09. Robin
10. Ebony

[mini-mart]

Nicole --- (ew)

Elyse 19
Adrianne 19
Katie 17
Kesse 16
Tessa 15
Shannon 15
Giselle 12
Nicole 08

So Unsexy:
09. Robin
10. Ebony

[Sentosa]

Giselle ---

Elyse 19
Adrianne 19
Katie 17
Kesse 16
Tessa 15
Shannon 15
Giselle 09
Nicole 08

So Unsexy:
09. Robin
10. Ebony

[mini-mart]

Nicole --
Gisele -

Elyse 19
Adrianne 19
Katie 17
Kesse 16
Tessa 15
Shannon 15
Giselle 08
Nicole 06

So Unsexy:
09. Robin
10. Ebony

[themilkshakeman]

Adrianne ++
Katie ++
Elyse. Nothing against her, I think she's a good model, but sexy? --

Katie 19
Adrianne 19
Kesse 17
Elyse 15
Shannon 15
Giselle 15
Tessa 15
Nicole 11
Robin 07
Ebony 01

[Sentosa]

Just a reminder, you have 3 credits, which can be a combination of pluses or minuses, awarded to/taken away from up to 3 contestants.

themilkshakeman:
Adrienne +
Katie +
Elyse -


Adrianne 20
Katie 18
Elyse 18
Kesse 16
Tessa 15
Shannon 15
Giselle 08
Nicole 06

So Unsexy:
09. Robin
10. Ebony

My scores:
Giselle --
Kesse -

Adrianne 20
Katie 18
Elyse 18
Kesse 15
Tessa 15
Shannon 15
Giselle 06
Nicole 06

So Unsexy:
09. Robin
10. Ebony

Edited by Sentosa, Dec 26, 2009 @ 3:42 PM.

[mini-mart]

Elyse +
Nicole --

Adrianne 20
Elyse 19
Katie 18
Kesse 15
Tessa 15
Shannon 15
Giselle 06
Nicole 04

So Unsexy:
09. Robin
10. Ebony

[nicenessness]

I always thought Tessa was pretty hot...

Adrianne 20
Elyse 19
Katie 18
Tessa 18
Kesse 15
Shannon 15
Giselle 06
Nicole 04

So Unsexy:
09. Robin
10. Ebony