What I like is that you have two awsome assholes on this show with Shane and Judd. And you could see the battle of the two challenge monsters Terry and Ozzy.
The people that I do believe belong on AS2 beyond a shadow of a doubt are: Ami (She along with Twila, Cirie and Steph are the top four female contestants since the first All-Stars) , Eliza (Isn't she a lawyer now? Does she really need the money that bad?), Katie, Ian, Judd, Gary, Terry, Cirie, Shane, Ozzy, Jonathan, Yau-Man, Michelle, and James.
The people that I am on the fence about are Courtney and Parvati (Don't get me wrong I think she is nice to look at but I am not sure if she belongs on AS2 or not).
Okay for the most part I agree with the female cast if this is the cast. I personally would get rid of Julie, Jenn, and Lydia (even though I love the fact that Jeff hates Lydia). I just do not feel that any of them warrant a position in All-Stars. Julie for the simple fact that not only did she not do anything but she is also Jeff's girlfriend. Jenn because even though she made it to the final four she had no screen time what so ever (and I agree that is she is apart of the cast it was more for what happened in her personal life). Lydia just did not add anything during her season as well. That being said the only one that I am dead set against having on there is Julie. I liked both Jenn and Lydia during their seasons. I just wish they did more.
Now if I could replace them with three other women my choices would be: Scout
: As much as I dislike this crazy old coot she is a memorable contestant. Twila
: Twila rocks plain and simple! First off she was the master mind of one of the biggest coups in Survivor history. And after the previous All-Stars there have been only really a handful of standout women on this show and IMHO Twila, Ami, Steph and Cirie are those women. The rest are not in the same league of these four women. As much as I dislike Ami and Guatemala Steph. Candice
: She was a great athlete and one of the better female players post All-Stars.Danielle
from Panama: She played a really good game espically near the end.Courtney
from Panama: Come on she was the most hated person on a tribe with Shane on it! That alone should have earned her a spot on AS2.Lisi
: Say what you want but Lisi much like Panama Courtney was interesting to watch in a trainwreck sort of way. Amy
from Guatemala: She was a good play who much like Bobby from Panama left way to early in the game. And plus she is from New England so I have to show her some respect.
As for the guys the only one I am not sure on is Coby. I just do not think he played all that good of a game. I would like to see him replaced with any of the following:Dre
: Because he is one of the most memorable people in the histroy of the show. Cao Boi
: Because he was just fucking nuts and him and Shane would be good together on the same team. Bobby
from Panama: Come on, if anyone can say Bobby does not belong then they should be smacked down. Granted he did not finish to high but his post Survivor blogs are the best and if given another chance I think he would do great.Rocky
: (Shit what if they put Judd, Shane and Rocky on the same tribe? That would make for some good TV bro...man.Rafe
: He was a very smart player who much like Ian made a very dumb move at the end of the game.
I could even make a case for Redneck James (Season 10) and Jamie (season 11).
And I would not mind seeing Johnny Fairplay come back. He alongside Richard Hatch and Boston Rob are the most memorable men in the shows history. However, if they do that then one could make the arguement of how is that fair for Mike from season 2? Because IMHO they should have both been on the original All-Stars.
Edited by BK1978, Nov 7, 2007 @ 4:36 AM.