187 replies to this topic

[ipopy]

1) She doesn't know how to write compelling characters with depth.

Edited by ipopy, Oct 22, 2007 @ 10:40 PM.

[BNScrubNurse]

2) Because she fired Isaiah.

*putting on her flame retardant clothing*

[Nikki528]

3) Because she squees as if she's a 12 year old fangirl.

[ipopy]

Let's see..reason # 4...hmmm..


4) Shonda puts out fake sneak peeks that show Meredith and Derek all happy only to pull the rug out from the fans at the end of the episode. That's dishonest, Shonda. YER FIRED!

[theneutralfork]

5) She's a serial killer of premeditated preportions!!! The constant character decimation should have her behind bars at the very least!

[BNScrubNurse]

6) Because she's reduced Cristina Yang, the most kickass character on the show, to the best friend with witty one liners.

Edited by BNScrubNurse, Oct 24, 2007 @ 11:23 AM.

[dayzee]

7. Continuity with characters, storylines ... and of course the general set

[DenyingS3]

8. Gizzie

[BNScrubNurse]

9) Because the bitch can't have it all.

[DenyingS3]

10- Because she came up with the shark jumping ferry arc and brought Denny back. Again.

[ipopy]

11) She is bringing on a new love interest for Derek when there is absolutely no fucking reason to.

[NYDocs]

12) Meredith and what she has become!

[ShepherdSquared]

Lucky 13) Because she created a *stereotypically* female character named Derek Shepherd.

Edited long time later... because being a female character is good, it's the stereotyped gender reversal that is meh.

Edited by ShepherdSquared, Apr 29, 2010 @ 8:18 AM.

[DenyingS3]

14) Because she lets Izzie and Derek get away with murder

[BNScrubNurse]

15) Because she thinks that George the manwhore who has slept with more people than anyone else on the show, is a decent guy.

[ShadowedAngel]

16) Because she infected Bailey with an uncurable form of Gizzie, and it will eat through her intenstines.

[julesnlove]

17) because she used Miranda Bailey, of all people, to excuse George

[DenyingS3]

18) Because according to the promo Izzie shaves her legs to have “hot sex” with George

[ipopy]

Ewwww Denying, that deserves 5 spots on the list!


19) Derek going on dates with anyone other then Meredith.

[snowfall]

20.) Because she's hellbent on proving to us all that women can't have it all.

[Gideon Brown]

21) Because she's so blinded by his looks, she can't see what a douchebag the leading man is.

[DenyingS3]

22) Because she insists on calling Meredith "an emotional cripple".

[BNScrubNurse]

23) Because at some point, she will put Cristina into a triangle.

[julesnlove]

24) Because she has made me hate Derek and therefore have given up my MerDer ship

[Gideon Brown]

25) Because she killed Ellis and Susan, and gave us Lexie

[DenyingS3]

25) Because she killed Ellis and Susan, and gave us Lexie

26) Because she didn’t kill Tatcher.

[ipopy]

27) Because she killed George's dad...

[Gideon Brown]

28) Because Izzie is still alive

[BNScrubNurse]

29) Because she's setting up George to sleep with Bailey.

[ShadowedAngel]

30) Because George has gotten the most ass on this show, and he's still gunning for more.