21167 replies to this topic

[Karoline]

I was thinking, since the first season is over, we could start some survival games. First off, we could do an episode survival. What do you guys think?

Rules:
There will be a list of the Supernatural episodes. All the episodes start with 15 points. To play, you have to cast a vote to give an episode either two more (++) or two fewer (--) points. Posters can only cast their votes once each calendar day (not 24 hours between), and only three votes at a time. (In other words, you can vote at both 11:59 and 12:01, but that's it for those two days.) When an episode has 0 points left, it is eliminated/gone. Once half of the total episodes are gone, episodes will only be allowed to receive only one point per vote (1+), but they can still be deducted two points (--), just so that the game doesn't go on forever. Also:

* You cannot vote for or against one episode more than once in a day by giving all three of your votes to that episode. You must add or subtract points from three different episodes.

* Post the updated standings with your vote as things go along, based on what the people above you have voted.

The episodes:
15 - Pilot
15 - Wendigo
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Phantom Traveler
15 - Bloody Mary
15 - Skin
15 - Hook Man
15 - Bugs
15 - Home
15 - Asylum
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Faith
15 - Route 666
15 - Nightmare
15 - The Benders
15 - Shadow
15 - Hell House
15 - Something Wicked
15 - Provenance
15 - Dead Man's Blood
15 - Salvation
15 - Devil's Trap

Lets get started!

[Kaiya]

All right, I am gonna give this a go. I hope I do it right!

The episodes:
15 - Pilot
15 - Wendigo
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Phantom Traveler
15 - Bloody Mary
15 - Skin
15 - Hook Man
15 - Bugs
17 - Home
15 - Asylum
15 - Scarecrow
17 - Faith
15 - Route 666
15 - Nightmare
15 - The Benders
15 - Shadow
15 - Hell House
15 - Something Wicked
15 - Provenance
15 - Dead Man's Blood
15 - Salvation
17 - Devil's Trap

[Karoline]

That's good, Kaiya, but even better if you do it like this:

Faith ++
Salvation ++
Asylum ++

19 - Faith
17 - Salvation
17 - Devil's Trap
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
15 - Pilot
15 - Wendigo
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Phantom Traveler
15 - Bloody Mary
15 - Skin
15 - Hook Man
15 - Bugs
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Route 666
15 - Nightmare
15 - The Benders
15 - Shadow
15 - Hell House
15 - Something Wicked
15 - Provenance
15 - Dead Man's Blood

[aithne414]

Devil's Trap ++
Dead in the Water ++
Hook Man --

19 - Faith
19 - Devil's Trap
17 - Salvation
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - Dead in the Water
15 - Pilot
15 - Wendigo
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Phantom Traveler
15 - Bloody Mary
15 - Skin
15 - Bugs
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Route 666
15 - Nightmare
15 - The Benders
15 - Shadow
15 - Hell House
15 - Something Wicked
15 - Provenance
15 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Hook Man

Edited by aithne414, May 8, 2006 @ 8:40 AM.

[Boadiccea]

Devil's Trap++
Salvation++
Faith++


21 - Faith
21 - Devil's Trap
21 - Salvation
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - Dead in the Water
15 - Pilot
15 - Wendigo
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Phantom Traveler
15 - Bloody Mary
15 - Skin
15 - Bugs
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Route 666
15 - Nightmare
15 - The Benders
15 - Shadow
15 - Hell House
15 - Something Wicked
15 - Provenance
15 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Hook Man

[Weesta]

++ Scarecrow
++ Devil's Trap
-- Bugs

23 - Devil's Trap
21 - Faith
21 - Salvation
17 - Scarecrow
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - Dead in the Water
15 - Pilot
15 - Wendigo
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Phantom Traveler
15 - Bloody Mary
15 - Skin
15 - Route 666
15 - Nightmare
15 - The Benders
15 - Shadow
15 - Hell House
15 - Something Wicked
15 - Provenance
15 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Bugs
13 - Hook Man

[simpatico]

Skin ++
Nightmare ++
Route 666 --

23 - Devil's Trap
21 - Faith
21 - Salvation
17 - Scarecrow
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - Dead in the Water
17 - Skin
17 - Nightmare
15 - Pilot
15 - Wendigo
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Phantom Traveler
15 - Bloody Mary
15 - The Benders
15 - Shadow
15 - Hell House
15 - Something Wicked
15 - Provenance
15 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Bugs
13 - Hook Man
13 - Route 666

[switchhitter33]

The Benders ++
Bugs --
Skin ++

23 - Devil's Trap
21 - Faith
21 - Salvation
19 - Skin
17 - Scarecrow
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - Dead in the Water
17 - Nightmare
17 - The Benders
15 - Pilot
15 - Wendigo
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Phantom Traveler
15 - Bloody Mary
15 - Shadow
15 - Hell House
15 - Something Wicked
15 - Provenance
15 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Hook Man
13 - Route 666
11 - Bugs

[simpatico]

Aw, c'mon guys, there was so much great brother stuff in "Bugs." "Route 666" was so much worse.

[simpatico]

It double-posted. Why, Tubey, why?

Edited by simpatico, May 8, 2006 @ 1:55 PM.

[switchhitter33]

Aw, c'mon guys, there was so much great brother stuff in "Bugs." "Route 666" was so much worse.

While I enjoyed the butt-smack and the steam shower, the plot was just SO terrible (insta-dawn WTF?) that I had to vote against it.

[faninohio]

Dead in the Water ++ (Because I am as shallow as they come and it's all about Jensen looking pretty!!)
Devil's Trap ++ (Because Jensen needs an Emmy for this episode!!!)
Route 666 ++ (Uh...see above...DEANSEX!!! Naked!Jensen!)


25 - Devil's Trap
21 - Faith
21 - Salvation
19 - Skin
19 - Dead in the Water
17 - Scarecrow
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - Nightmare
17 - The Benders
15 - Pilot
15 - Wendigo
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Phantom Traveler
15 - Bloody Mary
15 - Shadow
15 - Hell House
15 - Something Wicked
15 - Provenance
15 - Dead Man's Blood
15 - Route 666
13 - Hook Man
11 - Bugs

[qtpiehunni]

Hell House ++
Bloody Mary ++
Wendigo ++ (SO many great lines in that episode)

25 - Devil's Trap
21 - Faith
21 - Salvation
19 - Skin
19 - Dead in the Water
17 - Scarecrow
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - Nightmare
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
17 - Hell House
17 - Wendigo
15 - Pilot
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Phantom Traveler
15 - Shadow
15 - Something Wicked
15 - Provenance
15 - Dead Man's Blood
15 - Route 666
13 - Hook Man
11 - Bugs

[EMOjunky]

Hell House -- (ugg - I like Bugs more than this ep - sorry)
Something Wicked ++ (Dean - need I say more)
Pilot ++ (Because even with all 22 eps - its still my favorite)


25 - Devil's Trap
21 - Faith
21 - Salvation
19 - Skin
19 - Dead in the Water
17 - Scarecrow
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - Nightmare
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
15 - Hell House
17 - Wendigo
17 - Pilot
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Phantom Traveler
15 - Shadow
17 - Something Wicked
15 - Provenance
15 - Dead Man's Blood
15 - Route 666
13 - Hook Man
11 - Bugs

[efh]

Devil's Trap ++
Something Wicked ++
Bugs -- (as fun as the plastic spiders were, insta-dawn was SUCH a let-down)

27 - Devil's Trap
21 - Faith
21 - Salvation
19 - Skin
19 - Dead in the Water
19 - Something Wicked
17 - Scarecrow
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - Nightmare
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
15 - Hell House
17 - Wendigo
17 - Pilot
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Phantom Traveler
15 - Shadow
15 - Provenance
15 - Dead Man's Blood
15 - Route 666
13 - Hook Man
9 - Bugs

Edited by efh, May 8, 2006 @ 5:34 PM.

[omelas]

Faith ++ Dean up on stage with Roy? Soooo good
Scarecrow++ Hated Meg but loved the brothers making up
Route 666 -- Die Cassie Die!

27 - Devil's Trap
23 - Faith
21 - Salvation
19 - Skin
19 - Dead in the Water
19 - Something Wicked
19 - Scarecrow
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - Nightmare
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
15 - Hell House
17 - Wendigo
17 - Pilot
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Phantom Traveler
15 - Shadow
15 - Provenance
15 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Route 666
13 - Hook Man
9 - Bugs

Edited by omelas, May 8, 2006 @ 10:17 PM.

[valeriel]

Devil's Trap ++
Salvation ++
Scarecrow ++


29 - Devil's Trap
23 - Faith
23 - Salvation
21 - Scarecrow
19 - Skin
19 - Dead in the Water
19 - Something Wicked
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - Nightmare
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
15 - Hell House
17 - Wendigo
17 - Pilot
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Phantom Traveler
15 - Shadow
15 - Provenance
15 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Route 666
13 - Hook Man
09 - Bugs

[simpatico]

++ Skin
++ Nightmare
-- Route 666

29 - Devil's Trap
23 - Faith
23 - Salvation
21 - Scarecrow
21 - Skin
19 - Dead in the Water
19 - Something Wicked
19 - Nightmare
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
17 - Wendigo
17 - Pilot
15 - Hell House
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Phantom Traveler
15 - Shadow
15 - Provenance
15 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Hook Man
11 - Route 666
09 - Bugs

[lynzibell]

++Faith (Sam's determination and DyingDean)
++Provenance (BigBroDean, mvid stealthness, HappSam, and the hotel room)
--Phantom Travler (It was just blah to me.)

29 - Devil's Trap
25 - Faith
23 - Salvation
21 - Scarecrow
21 - Skin
19 - Dead in the Water
19 - Something Wicked
19 - Nightmare
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
17 - Wendigo
17 - Pilot
17 - Provenance
15 - Hell House
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Shadow
15 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Phantom Traveler
13 - Hook Man
11 - Route 666
09 - Bugs

[Jonisa]

++ Pilot (Just because it was so awesome.)
-- Route 666 (The only episode I have no desire to watch again. Couldn't stand Cassie.)
++ Nightmare (Another favorite of mine)

29 - Devil's Trap
25 - Faith
23 - Salvation
21 - Scarecrow
21 - Nightmare
21 - Skin
19 - Dead in the Water
19 - Something Wicked
19 - Pilot
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
17 - Wendigo
17 - Provenance
15 - Hell House
15 - Dead In The Water
15 - Shadow
15 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Phantom Traveler
13 - Hook Man
09 - Route 666
09 - Bugs

[Karoline]

Faith ++ (My favorite episode.)
Scarecrow ++ (Very exciting and nervewrecking.)
Route 666 -- (It was just bad. Despite the DeanSex.)

29 - Devil's Trap
27 - Faith
23 - Salvation
23 - Scarecrow
21 - Skin
21 - Nightmare
19 - Dead in the Water
19 - Something Wicked
19 - Pilot
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
17 - Wendigo
17 - Provenance
15 - Hell House
15 - Shadow
15 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Phantom Traveler
13 - Hook Man
09 - Bugs
07 - Route 666

Edited by Karoline, May 9, 2006 @ 5:32 AM.

[Weesta]

++ Devil's Trap
++ Faith
++ Scarecrow

31 - Devil's Trap
29 - Faith
25 - Scarecrow
23 - Salvation
21 - Skin
21 - Nightmare
19 - Dead in the Water
19 - Something Wicked
19 - Pilot
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
17 - Wendigo
17 - Provenance
15 - Hell House
15 - Shadow
15 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Phantom Traveler
13 - Hook Man
09 - Bugs
07 - Route 666

[Kaiya]

Scarecrow ++
Dead in the Water ++
Skin ++

31 - Devil's Trap
29 - Faith
27 - Scarecrow
23 - Salvation
23 - Skin
21 - Nightmare
21 - Dead in the Water
19 - Something Wicked
19 - Pilot
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
17 - Wendigo
17 - Provenance
15 - Hell House
15 - Shadow
15 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Phantom Traveler
13 - Hook Man
09 - Bugs
07 - Route 666

Edited by Kaiya, May 9, 2006 @ 6:17 AM.

[qtpiehunni]

Devil's Trap ++
Hell House ++
Nightmare ++

33 - Devil's Trap
29 - Faith
27 - Scarecrow
23 - Salvation
23 - Skin
23 - Nightmare
21 - Dead in the Water
19 - Something Wicked
19 - Pilot
17 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
17 - Wendigo
17 - Provenance
17 - Hell House
15 - Shadow
15 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Phantom Traveler
13 - Hook Man
09 - Bugs
07 - Route 666

[faninohio]

Route 666 ++ (Sorry, can't let it die...JA's back groovin'...works for me!!)
Home ++ (THE phone call...'nuff said)
Phantom Traveler ++ (Because it's so darn funny!)


33 - Devil's Trap
29 - Faith
27 - Scarecrow
23 - Salvation
23 - Skin
23 - Nightmare
21 - Dead in the Water
19 - Something Wicked
19 - Pilot
19 - Home
17 - Asylum
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
17 - Wendigo
17 - Provenance
17 - Hell House
15 - Shadow
15 - Dead Man's Blood
15 - Phantom Traveler
13 - Hook Man
09 - Bugs
09 - Route 666

[aithne414]

Asylum ++ (Much love for this episode, with Kat and her "YOU FACE IT!")
Pilot ++ (Gotta give it some love... it set up the rest of the series so well)
DMB -- (Had its moments, but I didn't like the camerawork or direction or something... it just didn't grab me)

33 - Devil's Trap
29 - Faith
27 - Scarecrow
23 - Salvation
23 - Skin
23 - Nightmare
21 - Dead in the Water
21 - Pilot
19 - Something Wicked
19 - Home
19 - Asylum
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
17 - Wendigo
17 - Provenance
17 - Hell House
15 - Shadow
15 - Phantom Traveler
13 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Hook Man
09 - Bugs
09 - Route 666

[BoE]

Devil's Trap ++
Faith ++
Phantom Traveler ++

35 - Devil's Trap
31 - Faith
27 - Scarecrow
23 - Salvation
23 - Skin
23 - Nightmare
21 - Dead in the Water
21 - Pilot
19 - Something Wicked
19 - Home
19 - Asylum
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
17 - Wendigo
17 - Provenance
17 - Hell House
17 - Phantom Traveler
15 - Shadow
13 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Hook Man
09 - Bugs
09 - Route 666

[Bitterswete]

Asylum ++ (Classic horror premise done darned well.)
Hell House ++ (The funny. The lines. The jokes. Priceless.)
Shadow ++ (So many good scenes.)

35 - Devil's Trap
31 - Faith
27 - Scarecrow
23 - Salvation
23 - Skin
23 - Nightmare
21 - Dead in the Water
21 - Pilot
21 - Asylum
19 - Something Wicked
19 - Home
19 - Hell House
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
17 - Wendigo
17 - Provenance
17 - Phantom Traveler
17 - Shadow
13 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Hook Man
09 - Bugs
09 - Route 666

[Boadiccea]

Something Wicked++(Dean angst, Dean's killer face, lots of brotherly love)
Faith++(Awww, Woobie Dean)
Devil's Trap++(Just because there's a bad moon on the rise)

37 - Devil's Trap
33 - Faith
27 - Scarecrow
23 - Salvation
23 - Skin
23 - Nightmare
21 - Dead in the Water
21 - Pilot
21 - Asylum
21 - Something Wicked
19 - Home
19 - Hell House
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
17 - Wendigo
17 - Provenance
17 - Phantom Traveler
17 - Shadow
13 - Dead Man's Blood
13 - Hook Man
09 - Bugs
09 - Route 666

[Rant]

Something's gotta die...

-- Hookman: The girl of the week made me cringe so badly.
-- Bugs: It's been said before - instadawn? WTF?
-- Route 666: VroomVroom! Fear the ridiculous racist truck!

37 - Devil's Trap
33 - Faith
27 - Scarecrow
23 - Salvation
23 - Skin
23 - Nightmare
21 - Dead in the Water
21 - Pilot
21 - Asylum
21 - Something Wicked
19 - Home
19 - Hell House
17 - The Benders
17 - Bloody Mary
17 - Wendigo
17 - Provenance
17 - Phantom Traveler
17 - Shadow
13 - Dead Man's Blood
11 - Hook Man
07 - Bugs
07 - Route 666