I watched the trailer for this show on futoncritic this morning and I was blown away by how funny I thoughts it was. I didn't think it would be anything worth my time based on the episode description but I was pleasantly suprised. It had a "Malcolm in the Middle" feel to it. The youngest child in it reminded me alot of of youngest on "Malcolm" as well. But it seemed like a lot of fun and it was nice seeing The Janitor in another role and this role seems to fit his style of comedy perfectly. I'm also one of few that finds Patricia Heaton funny in comedic roles.

I got a Malcolm and the Middle vibe too but this just seemed nothing special. Maybe it's because i'm not a fan of Patricia Heaton i dunno.

Very, very cringe worthy. Every scene was fully predictable and extremely overdone. I felt very embarrassed for these well-known actors. Will NOT watch again.

VERY Malcolm in the Middle. That whispering/repeating words that the youngest son did? My youngest son does it too. I almost fell out of my chair. If anybody knows what the technical term for it is, please PM me.

Wow, just wow... I mean the camera movement, edit pacing, music drops, the whole shebang was lifted from "Malcolm" to the point there's a case to be made for copyright infringement.

As for the actors, yeah, Kattan, Brian Doyle-Murry, the lady DA on "Bones" and a few other familiar faces appearing... makes me sad. I'm quite sure they know this is a POS, but hey when the network trends favor reality programming and "Leno" five nights a week over scripted programming, these guys are just looking for a way to keep up with the house payments in a shrinking job market.

Just couldn't have been worse.

Granted, I have a low tolerance for sitcoms, but there were really no laughs at all in this. And I *like* Patricia Heaton and the Scrubs guy.

Really, this made Heaton's last show Back To You look like a classic.

Not impressed at all, although in the end I did find it cute and a little heart warming. But otherwise I very quickly added it (and Hank) to the sweepstakes race along with Accidentally on Purpose and the forgotten for 2nd canceled show of the season.

That said, I must add that even though I saw it coming a mile away, I could not help but laugh until I cried at the Show Choir debacle when the daughter got distracted and forgot to put down the riser. I can't remember the last time I've laughed that hard at a sitcom. I'm glad I came back after switching over to Countdown with Keith Olbermann for a few minutes.

the term for what the youngest son was doing is echolalia

This is a sitcom and I laughed. Out loud, very hard several times. One time uncontrollably for a good while. Not sure what else it needed to do. Much better than Hank before it. I do wish they had just kept making "Back to You" though.

I love Patricia Heaton and thought she was hilarious in this. I'll keep watching. I never really watched Malcolm much so any comparisons don't bother me at all. Although I did see it a few times and the youngest kid here reminded me of Dewey. I thought the youngest actor (Aticus?) was adorable, and found it refreshing that the daughter was so awkward. I'm kind of sick of the precocious, unrealistically attractive teenage girls in most sitcoms and dramas. I love that Patricia is so down to earth in real life, and I think that makes her portrayal of the stressed-out, harried mother so believable. It probably helps that I recently had a drivers license photo that made me kind of horrified at the difference between now and my last one 6 years ago... so I could totally relate to the whole "what the hell happened to me?!!" thing.

This was easily the funniest new comedy of the season! I loved it...

I enjoyed it and laughed quite a bit. I saw half of Hank before it and unfortunately, didn't laugh once even though I am a HUGE Frasier fan.

The dad cracked me up the most. The youngest son is adorable and like others, reminded me of Dewey. Are those kids related?

Like AnnaRose said, it's refreshing to see a geeky teen girl instead of the unrealistic ones we normally see on most shows.

I'll be watching it again next week.

Maybe my expectations were really low, but this was a lot better than I thought it would be. I mean I was genuinely shocked that I enjoyed it so much.


Absolutely. So very sick of the dumb boy-crazy "hot" teenage girls that litter TV.

I looked it up and found out this was a pilot actually shot in 2007 with Rikki Lake as the star, and it wouldn't sell. They recast Patricia Heaton and ABC bought it.

I agree with most here - it's too much a rip off of Malcolm in the Middle with a scant touch of Married with Children. If I had to guess, probably a swing and a miss. Patricia Heaton is just off my radar.

The voiceover bugged. The jokes had potential but were all through the promos. I'll give it another episode.

Compared to Hank, The Middle was a brilliant masterpiece. And I was so happy to notice this show's absence of a laugh track. Thank you sitcom gods!

Matt Roush has given The Middle positive reviews, and the Futon Critic wrote that it's genuinely funny, feels like it comes from an astonishingly real place, and had no complaints about anything that didn't work: Review.

I can't imagine Hank not getting a big drop-off in audience after that brutally painful pilot, but I'm hoping The Middle is able to maintain its high numbers, and keep bringing the funny. (I read that it was number one in its time period last night.)

This show is just a rip-off of MALCOLM IN THE MIDDLE. I got that vibe from the various promos. How right I was when watching this piece of crap.

I thought this show was well done and found myself laughing at multiple points. I'll be watching next week.

I will not watch this again, this was very painfully unfunny. And never thought I'd ever make a comment like this (as I am not a feminists, in fact I'm the opposite of that) but this was just stupidly sexist. Oh, my catch-phrase is I'm a car matchmaker, because I'm such a salesWOMAN. And then it persists with - wow this is a great car with a... a.... an integrated steering-wheel - yeah, that's all I have in my technical vocabulary - I'm such a ditsy salesWOMAN. Just disgusting.

Ha... and she was right. She could not even come close to all the other salesmen who were all men, there was no other woman there. And how many saleswomen do you see at car dealerships anyway, I've never seen one. Their stereotyping is realistic. The show however is very bad. Lots of over the top acting which was neither cute, witty or funny. Will not watch again.

I am from Indiana:

I would almost be offended if it wasn't so true of our small towns. We do have car lots and churches on every corner, corn fields out the wazoo and "Show Choir" IS everything. :)

Now they have to do an episode on county fairs (complete with tractor pulls), poker runs and Christmas parades.

Loving it.

Wow. I loved this show. Perhaps I just watched it at a moment that I really needed to laugh, and it delivered. While I hope it lasts, I am doubtful. Hopefully it will outlive Hank, Cougar Town and Accidentally on Purpose, which I think are all just awful.

I liked this show-I was surprised I did. I agree it is a little Malcolm in the Middle . Speaking as someone who does not have childern I found the show funny because the kids are far from perfect and the parents didn't think that they are. I've worked with people who always talk about their kids as if they walked on water and act as if they are perfect parents--YEAH Right.

Not so sure it will last because I think for a lot of people it might be close to real life.

This show is funny, but I'm not feeling Patricia Heaton as the lead. I wish they had picked a different actress. Heaton just seems too uptight for Frances.

Seriously, she was wound tighter than a drum in that episode. It was exhausting just to watch her.

Loved that she went to such lengths to get Brick his book tho.

On that note, who in the world names a child "Brick"... lol

They mentioned something in the pilot about giving their boys "tough" names so they wouldn't get picked on or something to that effect...hence Brick and Axel.

I love that Axel's punishment was that he had to stay within 5 feet of a parent at all times...I'll have to remember that one!

I thought the second episode was equally hilarious as the first, and I laughed out loud a lot. I was glad the older son Axle had more to do in this episode and thought the actor was spot-on and very funny, as was the whole five foot thing as punishment. Also, I just adore that young actor who plays Brick. So cute! I just want to pinch his cheeks.

I think Patricia Heaton's delivery is perfect, and I could see if she played the character at the manic level of the melt-down at the end all the time it would be annoying... but I thought her freakout was petty funny, especially the looks of her family at the end of it. The husband (Janitor? What's his name again? Mike?) also has a terrific presence and delivery. He and Heaton play off each other well.

And by a strange coincidence, after receiving some dented cans from Amazon the night before the episode aired, I googled to find out about the safety of it, and came across a video from a news piece about a store just like the expired foods emporium on the show... people really do shop at those stores apparently taking a chance on expired and damaged food products. Yikes!

"We're listening for peas people!" LOL!

I don't normally like blue-collar sitcoms, but this one amuses me and makes me laugh. That's all I'm really looking for in a comedy. (And it's surprising how many sitcoms don't even elicit a laugh, let alone a grin.) So yeah, this show may not be ground-breaking... but the laughs are enough for me.

I thought that was rather cool, never would have thought of it. I too, will have to remember it. :)

I was so proud of the Father for keeping it enforced, of course, until he allowed the girl to be in "The 5 foot" area, was funny, tho.

Good news: The show was just picked up for the rest of the season (22 episodes)!

That's great news, JustinCase! I was a little concerned about the ratings even though The Middle improves a bit on its dreadful lead-in Hank. Too bad ABC didn't keep Samantha Who or one of my faves, Miss Guided. Either of those would have been a much better complement to the new comedy night than Hank.

Here is an interview with Patricia Heaton and Neil Flynn, where they discuss preparing for a single camera show, among other things.

And here is a TVGuide interview with Neil Flynn.

I think the second episode is much better than the pilot. I think Francis' delivery is much more likable.

Oh Sue, trying out for everything that she would fail miserably at. Axel is slowly becoming less annoying. 5 feet proximity rule is hilarious, funny Axel didn't attempt to stray away from his parents.

Not feeling Brick at all. He's not as adorable as Dewey in Malcolm in the Middle. And yes, he'll get that comparison all the time.

Thanks for sharing... I was hoping it would get a chance.

I so much love this show, makes me laugh out loud! I never watched Malcolm in the Middle so I don't have that comparison to make. I just really love the characters and my friends and I agree that it is so funny because we can identify with the family on a lot of things. I very much agree with others who like the fact that the kids are not perfect sitcom kids. Can identify with the money struggles and the not being able to replace the broken dryer (at this time we have a 21 year old broken washer that we can't afford to replace that my husband tried to fix, bless his heart!). Nice also to see a family that does not have a perfect house, with the same types of issues a lot of us deal with that we can find humor in. Glad this was picked up for a full season!

I am loving this show! I was worried I wouldn't like it because Patricia Heaton would make me think of the Everybody Loves Raymond days and especially the gentleman that plays her husband (Mike I think) I wouldn't be able to get Scrubs out of my mind but yeah they are pulling it off nicely and this is a geniunly funny show!

In the pilot they said something to the effect that if you give your kid "cool" name thinking it would actually make them cool, it doesn't always work.

I expected not to like this show. I am not even the demographic it is aimed at (I am a 21 year old, single college student) but I found it all so funny!

I love the awkward teenage daughter, the 5 feet punishment for Axel was hilarious (him making out with the girl... "he drew her into the perimeter) and Brick's weird whispering. But of course, Patricia Heaton is the best. She is so good at being realistic and funny without giving you second hand embarrassment.

So glad it was picked up for a full season and also glad that in the front page poll 16% of people picked it as their favorite comedy.

Patricia Heaton is the worst. I can almost take the kids, their acting is OK, just the writing is bad. But in her case, both are bad - she's way over the top annoying.

I thought I would hate this show, but I like it a lot. I like that they aren't making working parenthood a breeze. You have to wonder how all those working parents on TV manage, and this show doesn't make it look easy. I also like that they aren't rolling in inexplicable amounts of money, and the kids are not all perfectly coiffed. It has enough fanciful stuff that they're not being grim, but enough reality that they're not being insultingly glib.

Their family situation, particularly their financial situation is much more believable than the family on Modern Family who live in an expensive house with no visible means of supporting that lifestyle.

I think the actors playing the two younger kids are brilliant. They are such odd characters and they can really pull it off. The older son character seems to fit too neatly into the teenage-boy-as-clueless-dick stereotype.

Episode 3 is decently better.

Sue can't really catch a break. Every time she tries to put her face forward, she humiliates herself. I would like to see her and her crush together if it is possible, that would be her silver lining.

Axel is growing on me, I think. As long as he won't act obnoxious all the time then yeah. Although I know for sure something is bound to be bad happening when Francis takes a 15 minute alone time, seeing it happening is amusing.

"Why didn't anyone thought about calling dad?"
"'Cos dad hates it when we call him at work"

Oh, stated as a matter of fact, but hilarious.

Axel: "Nobody wants to see that..."
Sue: "I think old people kissing is sweet..."

Sue's jab masked in a compliment. Heh.

The sad part is, it wasn't a jab on Sue's part. From what we know of Sue, it's right in character for her to say something like that and not realize it's a jab.

I don't know why but I was touched by the scene when Brick found Sue crying. He seemed to be sad to see she was crying. Also, that we didn't get the typical teenage freakout complete with yelling at Brick to get away.

This show is just clicking for me. I actually watch it before I watch Modern Family and Cougar Town. I didn't think that would be the case coming in. I just enjoy spending time with this family. No one is this group is one dimensional.

Brick is weird but not clueless.

Sue is clueless but not stupid. I also love that she isn't the typical teenage girl on t.v. full of hormones and mood swings.

Axel is a smart-ass but not a complete jerk. Also, i've noticed how much he doesn't really seem to mind being around his family. He even seemed to be really smiling when Kattan was breaking down Wife Swap.

Mom Heck is a little uptight but not completely shrill.

Dad Heck is does seem to care and come through for his family even seems like he doesn't care.

If i'm crazy for loving the show then lock me in a straight jacket right now.

I agree with y'all about this show being terrific. Its not laugh out loud funny, but its very enjoyable and has a great heart.

I think the cast genuinely seems to like each other and it really shows in their chemistry. To me it reminds me of very early Roseanne years mixed with some Malcom in the Middle.

I hope it keeps getting better.

I'm really enjoying this so far. Enough insanity to make it funny, yet not so over the top that it's unrealistic. And a basset hound in an oxygen mask being wheeled around in a little red wagon? That's just priceless!

I have been pleasantly surprised at how consistently funny this show is. It feels good to laugh again! I only wish ABC had a better show to pair this with than "Hank."

I've finally sampled the new comedies and this is my favorite. It makes me laugh out loud, unlike say, Modern Family, which just makes me want to fast-forward. TM reminds me most of Aliens in America, rather than Malcolm in the Middle.

The teenage boy's boxer shorts make me chuckle--growing up, my friend's older brothers and my own college roommates just wandered around in boxer shorts.

Where did they find the actor that plays Brick? I honestly think that him and the actor that plays Manny on Modern Family deserve to be nominated for Best Actors in a comedy this year. They're hysterical. Brick's entire storyline with that girl was cracking me up - "I'll do any type of social interaction that you ask - just NOT with her!" Too funny.

Awwww poor Sue !!! She (and family) worked their butts off for that trip and then to have it all ruined. So glad she found her "Voice", she was just too meek for me.

Brick certainly had his hands full, wonder if that's how the younger ones are doing it these days, "You're my boyfriend". "Okay"....

Dad impressed me in this episode, he came across as a hands on parent and seemed to really care for his family.

I really love this show! At first I liked it, but now I'm willing to commit.

Loved the visual of Dad with the beer, teen with the soda, young kid with the juice.

Really, I loved both stories this week.

It grosses me out that Axl walks around in his underwear, though. Is that something teens do? It's not even like he's particularly cut. He doesn't seem to be showing off. It's weird, and kind of too much of a quirk for me.

Sue's postcards just cracked me up. "Coming home tomorrow. I can't believe how mad I am."
And Mike getting cowed by the little girl was great too. "How are you going to make me?" "Um. Brick, your girlfriend's here!"