I've played this on a bunch of other threads and figured it could easily transfer over to the magical world of VM. The rules are simple: one poster asks a question and gives two possible responses. The replier picks one of the options, including an explanation as to why if he/she wishes, and then asks a new question. Sometimes you get to pick between two great choices, but it often comes down to having to pick between the lesser of two evils!

One of these characters can magically come back to life! Would You Rather:

Have Lilly alive next season

or

Have Cassidy alive next season

That's a toughie...I think I'd rather have Lilly alive. If Beave hadn't raped Veronica, I think I would chose him, but he did, so I didn't :D

Would you rather:

Have Mac as a regular cast member?

-OR-

Have Lamb as a regular cast member?

I pick Lamb. We already know what its like to have in him 16 episodes in one season. We don't yet know whether a little Mac goes a long way.



Would you rather

have one more mindblowing, amazing season

or

have five more good seasons?

One more mind-blowing one

Would you rather have Lamb be . . .

the evil, manipulative Big Bad of S3

or

the smarmy, lazy, semi-corrupt Sheriff for years to come?

I think I'd like my Lamb as a Big Bad of season three. Not really sure why, as I love Lamb and MM, I just have a feeling that if they did that, I would be very impressed.

Would You Rather:

Have Logan and Veronica break up two or three episodes into season three and have UST for the rest of the season, with possibility they'd get back together later?

-OR-

Have Logan and Veronica together all season, happy(or as happy as they can get) then have them break up at the end of the season for good?

Ooh, can I answer all of these?

I would rather have Cassidy alive. I would rather have Mac as a regular, just because Lamb would probably be in more anyway. I would rather have five good seasons, just because I live for this show. I would definitely choose the UST because I could not stand years of Logan and Veronica hating each other.

Would You Rather:

Have them kill Wallace, but keep the status of the other characters?

-OR-

Bring Duncan back so Veronica can cheat on Logan with him?

Bring Duncan back-- because I don't want Veronica to lose another best friend.

Would you rather
-Have Jackie come back

Or

Have Lamb as a season regular

I'm so glad people are playing!

I'd much, much rather have Lamb as a season regular. I find him intriguing and think he provides some of the best snark on the show, while Jackie does nothing for me other than mildly grate on my nerves.

One of the following characters undergoes a major transformation next season! Would You Rather:

Dick becomes a devout born again Chrsitian

or

Wallace becomes dark and destructive

Dick as a Christian thanks

Would you rather see:

Mac become dark and destrutive

Or

Veronica become dark and destructive

I would rather Mac become dark and destructive. I may be in the minority but Mac is just EH. While she does give good funny, I would not miss her if she wasn't there. Plus, I can't have Veronica becoming destructive. Who's going to help her out? Logan? I need her sane.

Would you rather:
Meg was still alive, but Duncan is still in Neptune and still with Veronica

or

Duncan is gone and Meg is dead

Duncan gone and Meg dead, please.

Would you rather

Have Troy (Aaron Ashmore) return

or

Have Luke (Sam Huntington) return

Definitely Troy. He is cute, charming and just a great character. Though NOT romantically linked with Veronica. I LOVE and adore Troy. He lights up my screen everytime.

Would you rather:
Wallace never returned to Neptune

or

Wallace returned but got sent to jail to killing the wino

I'd rather have Wallace gone altogether, than in jail. Wallace behind bars would be too depressing.

Would you rather

Have Wallace try to put a move on Veronica

or

Have Weevil try to put a move on Veronica

Ewww! Is neither an option?
I guess Weevil. He can try but that doesn't mean he will succeed. If Wallace and V ever dated it will ruin the infrasrtucture of their whole friendship. They are great together as friends.

Would you rather:

Cassidy never been a Shark but Logan was

or

Keep it the way it was, rape and all

Keep it the way it was, rape and all. As much as it pains me to say so.

Would you rather:

Keith had proposed to Alicia in Chicago

OR

Keith really had started dating Rebecca James again in I am God

I would rather Keith proposed, because I actually really enjoyed Keith and Alicia together, and maybe then he'd be more trusting of her and they wouldn't break up and Veronica and Wallace would become step-siblings. Wacky Brady Bunch hijinks anyone?

Would you rather:

Miss Dumbass be resurrected and become a season regular as Veronica's new professor

Or

Wanda Varner be pulled from the deepest pits of hell and become Veronica's new friend

To belatedly chime in on an above question: Troy, Troy and Troy. I liked Luke, but I'll pick Troy over virtually anyone!

I might be the only peson who didn't hate Wanda, and I think her being revealed as a 'narc' brought up some interesting issues about the ethics of Veronica's own 'undercover', often deceptive investigative work. I did, however, dislike the ultra-pointless Dumbass. So, yeah..I'd rather Wanda!

One of these 'MotW' characters will be getting recurring role! Would you rather see:

Casey Gant (reformed '09er from "Drinking the Kool-Aid")

or

Justin (guy who finds out his father had a sex change operation in Meet John Smith)

Ooh, I'll take this one! Casey. And for nothing more than purely superficial reasons.

Would you rather

Be locked in a room for four hours with Dick

or

Be locked in a room for four hours with Gia

Oh god, that's a tough one...I'd take Dick. At least he'd amuse me, Gia would just irritate the holy hell out of me.

Would you rather:

Lose Wallace from the cast

-OR-

Lose Keith from the cast

Be Locked in a room for 4 hours with Dick. I find Gia as annoying as Logan does.

Would you rather:

Wallace die?

Or Keith?

Oops, too slow. Funny that Josillicious and I are on the exact same wavelength.

Wallace or Keith. Dammit, that's so hard. Uhm... Wallace.

Would you rather

that Duncan comes back and becomes Veronica's new girlfriend

OR

that Troy comes back, but he and Veronica starts hating eachother

I'd rather lose Wallace; Keith and Veronica's relationship is such a major part of the show. All of my favorite scenes are with them, and I wouldn't like the show nearly as much without him. I'd hate for Wallace to die tho; hardly seems fair for V to lose two friends.

Would have rather have a season filled with:
Totally pointless Buffy cameos
or
Logical and plot-furthering Top Model cameos?

For Karloline's, (since it wasn't answered) I would much rather Troy come back and they hate each other rather than Duncan EVER come back. He was just a bad boyfriend. Veronica forgives him for anything. He didn't tell her about Meg being pregnant and when she finds out he says it has nothing to do with them. Plus he has problems emoting things. Ugh!

And, for Poor Grace's definitely pointless Buffy cameos. There is no question about it.

Would you rather:

Lianne come back and continue drinking and being the horrible person she is

or

Lynn come back and have been behind the bus crash

So many things wrong with that statement but I'll just assume you meant what I thought you meant.

In that case I chose Troy coming back.

I'd chose the logical and plot-furthering Top Model cameos even though I'm sure that's an unpopular choice.

Would you rather:

Fluffy, happy, schmoopy L/V
or
Dark, Angsty, Gutwrenching L/V

I actually prefer V. and L. as individual characters than as a couple, but I'd go with fluffy, happy L and V, if only because I really don't want lots of screen time taken up with 'ship-related angst.

One of the characters discovers that he/she is gay. Would You Rather It Be:

Weevil

or

Dick

Oh, totally Dick. Even straight I swear he has the hots for Logan.

Would you rather

Have a second coma!baby storyline

or

Have One Angry Veronica, Part 2.

One Angry Veronica part 2. It's only one episode.

Would you rather...

see more of Veronica's flashback long hair


or

Argyle. Argyle argyle argyle.

Argyle. Hey, chicks can't resist it. Plus, I like V much better with shorter hair.

Would you rather...

Cassidy comes back from the dead

or

Meg comes back from the dead

Meg. Cassidy is a killer and rapist.

Would you rather:
Paris Hilton guest star again? or

Kristin Cavalleri guest star again?

Gah, that's a tough one. I guess I'd go for Paris Hilton, since as much I loathe her, I happened to really like the episode she was in and feel she (unsurprisngly) did a fine enough job playing a pampered snotty bitch.

Keith's getting married! Only, it's not exactly to the ideal woman. Would You Rather He Marry:

Kendall Casablancas

or

Celeste Kane, recently divorced from Jake

Definately Mommy Sneerest. At least she hasn't slept with half of Neptune...as far as we know.

Veronica and Mac have to share a room with one other roommate. Would you rather it be:

Ashlee Simpson

or

Jessica Simpson

Jessica Simpson. Ashlee annoys me to no end.

Would you rather have had...

a half season full of Veronica/Duncan sex scenes or

a half season with no Logan/Veronica scenes (and by that, I mean there's no interaction between them at all).

half a season of V/D sex scenes, because I'd rather see those than have no logan/ Veronica together.

Would you rather see
Charisma Carpentar return as Kendall

-or-

have Sarah Michelle Gellar as a new character

Definitely SMG. I love Charisma Carpenter, but Kendall's character was IMO just your typically gold digging witch and not especially interesting. Frankly, for me one episode of Kendall would have been enough. SMG, however, is IMO a fantastic actress who could play a really layered and compelling character if given the right role.

Would You Rather:

Veronica spend most of next season as a socially accepted, popular, even borderline perky '09-esque character determined to make 'normal' the watchword

or

Have Veronica spend most of next season as the marginalized, feisty underdog outcast BUT have her so isolated that she's no longer even close with Wallace or Mac.

I'll go with feisty, isolated underdog, even if she's alienated from Mac and Wallace. I'm still scarred from Veronica's first foray into 'normalcy.'

The writers decide that one of 'em has to go:

Would you rather it be

Logan's XTerra

or

Veronica's Le Baron

This decision caused me more anguish than it should have! I guess I'll have to go with the Xterra although I have a deep affection for them both!

If only one could stay on the show, would you rather it be:
Cliff or Lamb?

I’d vote for Lamb. As would Cliff.

RT values your opinion and you get to pick the Hearst rapist for the alternate TRoG ending. Is it

Troy

or

Dean

The rapist would absolutely be Dean. I could never do that to my cute, witty, charming, adorable smile, Troy. He is such a great character.

I asked this earlier but it wasignored. :( So, would you rather.

Lianne come back and continue drinking and being the horrible person she is

or

Lynn come back and have been behind the bus crash

I'd rather that Lianne come back and continue drinking and being the horrible person she is because at least it is in character, I don't think I could take another semi-decent (and really, she was only semi-decent -- she never stopped Aaron from abusing Logan) character turning out to be a truly evil person.

Say Backup were to find himself a new friend of the female persuasaion and they decided to have puppies, which breed would you prefer?

Doberman

or


Cocker Spaniel

A Doberman seems to be more Backup's type.

Would you rather:

Be spelunking

OR

Be strapped down on an anthill?

I'd rather be spelunking. That's not so bad compared to being strapped down on an ant hill. Those little bitches can bite. I think if you're in a cave you are covered up more and you are less likely to have something bite you. Plus I HATE and sort of bug.

Would you rather:

Logan have been sent to jail for killing Felix

or

Logan have been killed in the bus crash

I would rather Logan went to jail for killing Felix because at least the Veronica could visit him and he would be out later or he could pull a Prison Break and break out...

if Cassidy hadn't been behind the bus crash would you rather it had been

Gia

or

Dick

Gia, Dick's character is too lovably evil to be pure evil.

Would you rather:

Keith be killed in the plane crash in the season finale.

or

Logan have been killed by Beaver on the rooftop.

I hate to say this but I'd rather Keith died. Poor woobie has been through enough. He deserves to be alive and well and with Veronica.

Would you rather:

Gia be Veronica's new best friend

or

Have Lilly still alive and Veronica's best friend, but with bubblegum V.

Tough choice.

I'd rather have Gia be her new best friend. I like Veronica too much as she is.

Would you rather:

Meg refused to go out with Duncan and thus Meg never died and Duncan never had a reason to leave the show

OR

Duncan had killed Meg in an epileptic fit

I would rather Duncan had killed Meg in an epileptic fit. It would have made him interesting, which he sadly was not in season 2.

Would you rather...
Veronica had gotten pregnant by the Donut? or

Hannah had gotten pregnant by Logan?

Definitely Veronica. I was never very keen on Hannah, and I'm not especially interested in another storyline for her. It wasn't the fault of the actress, I just wasn't into a doe-eyed love interest for Logan. Even when I disliked him, I was more invested in Duncan than Hannah.

Would you rather:

Dick blames Veronica and Logan for Cassidy's death.

OR

Dick turns to Veronica and Logan for emotional support after Cassidy's death.

Toughie.
I'd say have Dick go to LoVe for some good ole' fashion consoling. That would be great to see Dick crying...

Okay WYR:

1) Have Logan break up with Veronica if/when Hannah returns
or,
2) Have Logan break up with Veronica for a one, Troy Van de Graff?

Hypothetically, of course...

I would really prefer a third option of 3) Have Logan break up with Veronica and get with Weevil but if I had to choose between the two I say option 1. Troy might turn Logan to ice and then where would we be?

WYR:

1. Veronica go to Hearst and become a normal college student, solving no mysteries

or

2. Veronica ditch college all together and spend her time hanging out with Logan and solving crime?

'Normal' Veronica definitely doesn't do it for me, and I'm a huge mystery buff, so I'll definitely pick the 'crime solving college drop-out' option.

Next Season, Would You Rather:

Deal with an annoyingly soapy 'Veronica's pregnant and doesn't know who the father is' storyline

or

Have a season in which Veronica isn't romantically involved with anyone---yes, L/V fans, that includes Logan ;)