Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: 4-7: "Back to School" 2005.11.03
TWoP Forums > Current TWoP Shows > The Apprentice > The Apprentice General Gabbery
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12
SunniLee
I never expected Donald Pimp in the Boardroom. If I were Adam, I'd have crawled under the table and stayed there for about a week. Damn. Getting outed as an alleged virgin on national television. Damn. There were way too many "pleeeease make it stop!" moments in that boardroom.

I guess I can get rid of my Markus-to-English dictionary now.


Oh god, even just watching that bit... I feel so unclean! I'm going to have to perform some elaborate purification ritual involving steel wool, lighter fluid, matches, holding my breath...[/quote]
Don't you worry. You just take yourself on over to the Scarred for Life thread in TV Potluck. They have a large supply of brain bleach. I'm sure if you explain the situation, they'll gladly give you an entire vat.

Important lessons learned: 1. Never, ever, ever underestimate Randal and his ideas. 2. Never, ever, ever mention the word "sex" in any context ever again in life. I think the world population is going to dip considerably after this.

Shirtless!Randal?
*pant* *pant*
*drool*
*KLUNK!*
peterredtail
I saw that Trump finally let Kelly out of the basement or was it his robot clone - what a strange stance he had - maybe he still thought he was at West Point under Sargent Donald's command.

Finally that rambling, babbling fool left...hey Markus if you disliked it so much - why not just quit? (see TA3).


Alla was ready to do anything to do a quick team switch & go along to the Kors-fest.[/quote]

Hmm, I thought I saw her skin turn green with envy with eyes for daggers directed at curly, larry and moe! She won't forget this lost opportunity in a hurry. But she could have stepped up to the plate a little better - but again it is a game and she had immunity so why put herself out too hard - after all it was fun to watch Clay do it.
FocusedApathy
off-topic
kindest demon

His reaction in the boardroom seemed to be based on the claims Alla and Adam made that his homosexuality made the people uncomfortable. They seemed to be trying to make his homosexuality an issue and maybe make Trump fire him both for anti-Semitism and his being gay.[/quote]

I actually thought Markus brought that up first, when Trump asked what had gone wrong. Then Trump did his Trumpish thing and ran with a ham-handed and faux-sensational interpretation of events rather than with reality. Which shouldn't be a surprise to Clay if he's ever, ever watched the show before. Alla in particular made a point of trying to move away from the whole Jewish issue and discuss the myriad other dumb-ass things Clay did and said during the presentation.

I can understand why Clay's upset, as his remarks did get pulled out of context, but I can totally see him pulling the full bitchy tantrum. Thus not only feeding his own stereotype, but getting pissy at Adam for the same thing he didn't think Adam should have gotten pissy with him over.
rubbersquash
I think Trump and Carolyn gave Markus many chances to speak for himself & the loss but Markus was so pleased with the attention that he got extremely tongue tied. He ambushed himself.
tiggeril

You understand this isn't a real job interview, don't you? The contestants on this game show sign a contract about 3 inches thick saying anything goes.[/quote]
I'm well aware that it isn't a "real" job interview. This is not my first foray into watching reality television. That being said, his decision reflects poorly on the Trump Organization as a whole, and on Trump as the owner personally. It says that Trump finds that sort of discourse acceptable on some level, and that's just not good for him, or anyone who works for him. It may not be true, and frankly, I think it's not. The problem is that it could be interpreted as condoning asking such personal questions in a professional situation.
mcwoohoo
But FocusedApathy why would Clay be talking about that? Adam's not gay and they were talking about going out to dinner and not sex.
Binet

Thought Randal's team rocked. I think Randal, Marshawn and Alla are all final four material.
[/quote]

That's certainly what it looked like, but given how close the ratings were, I can't help but wonder if we were shown the best of Randal et al.'s presentation and the worst of the other one.

Markus' final taxi ride was hilarious!
AlmondEyes


I think they should have done a seminar on avoiding corporate-speak. Then they could have utilized their assets and executed their results. Huh?[/quote]


And also maximized their potential, thought outside the box, and stepped up to the plate.[/quote][/quote]
. . . all while adding value to the task.
lovinbob

Clay realized Adam was offended, he apologized[/quote]
Actually, I believe he said, "If I have to apologize to you, then I'm sorry." He didn't feel he said anything wrong.

With that said, I respectfully submit that this discussion is on the road to nowhere. Each of us is going to experience comments and situations like those differently, and none of us knows what Clay was thinking or feeling. (I personally think he fed into a negative stereotype, one of the reasons being that the door was opened for him and he slid in, awkwardly, stupidly and offensively.) But the fact that Adam accepted Clay's "apology" and said he didn't believe he was an anti-Semite is enough for me to let go of my own indignation about it.

It's possible that Clay's dramatic anger had to do with a feeling he had that he was defamed (though I don't think he was). Should make for an interesting opening to next week's show!

To me, the ultimate (yet entertaining) tool was Trump.

Sometimes, I swear to God, I think Trump is autistic. He has absolutely no ability to read social situations.[/quote]
TOTALLY! Beyond his wildly inappropriate questioning of/assumptions about Adam, and his goofy "acceptance" of Clay's sexuality, how about his treatment of George?
At least twice, he was all: "I can see why YOU would be offended, George." Ugh! You don't need to be Jewish to be offended by a (potentially) anti-Semitic comment! Ugh!

And that is another way that Markus and Trump are, in fact, alike. Equally oblivious to the way they present themselves to the world.

AlmondEyes, thanks for adding value to the conversation by mentioning "adding value." That phrase used to have meaning till Adam beat it to death tonight.
msrayrudd
Read the thread before posting, please.
madted
This episode had it all! A gay, a virgin Jew and the village idiot!
I think that Markus' cab ride blathering was just as hilarious (if not more!) than the unconfortable cab ride o' four. Good stuff!
Lisetta

There were way too many "pleeeease make it stop!" moments in that boardroom.[/quote]
Yes, and the most amazing thing was they decided to not edit them out. What is Burnett thinking?

Re: Randall. I'm hoping he loses, in a classy way, before final two. He deserves better than being stuck in some closet space next to Melania's assistant having his considerable talents wasted doing PR for Trump for a year (while probably being publicly insulted like Kendra).

I -especially- hope that final two aren't Marshawn and Randall. Like last year's final of Tana and Kendra, following two white males in a row, that will just smack of tokenism, especially since Trump probably will pull the same cr*p he did with Kendra and not appreciate the very capable candidate who wins.

It's one thing to waste a couple of months with Trump, maybe getting some good public recognition. It's another to waste a year of your life working for this ass and getting to do...very little that means anything to anyone.
RhondaGC

I liked Marcus, and part of me is extremely relieved to see him off this trainwreck, because I think a combo of self-delusion, bad editing and a pinch of poor luck turned him into the made-for-TV tool that everyone seems to think he is.[/quote]
I didn't like him really, but I will agree that his "character" was probably manipulated, I mean, even more than they normally are on this show. And I highly suspect that the part tonight where he was trying to "explain" his idea to the group was heavily edited. It appeared to me that they took random parts of his explanation and pasted them together, leaving out large sections, to make him sound unintelligible. I'm not saying his idea was great or well-presented to start with, but I do suspect there was more going on there than we saw.

Of course, his comments in the taxi, which appear to not have been edited, are good evidence of the fact that he can talk for long periods of time and make no sense, so maybe I'm accusing the editors falsely.
Caitlin M
Trump likes to make everything awkward. Jesus.

Of course Clay isn't "anti-semitic." In fact, maybe I should've taped this so I can check but it sounded to me that, because Adam kept bringing up being a nice Jewish boy from Atlanta, Clay was making a joke of how much Adam had repeated it. I honestly think Adam saw it as a good way to put a target on Clay and save his own ass.

Then Trump asks Adam if he's a virgin. I guess Trump had a point about teaching a seminar on a foreign subject. But then he asks Clay if he's a "homosexual?" I was having major flashback of psycho-ass Chris screaming "I am NOT a homosexual!!" It was all just too awkward for words.

And then, just when you thought the awkward-fest was over, Markus opens his mouth to actually doubt that Trump wishes him luck -- how juvenile -- and Trump insults him right to his face... again!

This episode was just... odd. But I'm holding onto my early season prediction that we will have a black Apprentice this year. Randall and Marshawn are doing some fine ass-kickery. And I love them, so I'm happy.
Bassari99
Can't figure Markus out. Either he's a stoner, a plant or someone who realized he was in over his head and just wanted to go home. Could Markus have actually wanted to be fired? He was beyond incoherent tonight, inexplicably cranky and obstreperous. Who in their right mind brings a yo-yo to an event like that and then very pointedly pulls it just to illustrate the level of boredom and detachment they feel. For his own indecipherable reasons, Markus was itching to go home.
FocusedApathy

But FocusedApathy why would Clay be talking about that? Adam's not gay and they were talking about going out to dinner and not sex. [/quote]

My interpretation of it.

Adam: Were talking about sex in the work place tonight. Now lets talk about dating and going to to dinner, etc.

Clay: Don't listen to him. I know that you are surprised that when you thought you were coming to a class about semi-anonymous sexual encounters at the work place, and this dweeb is talking about going out for dinner. Don't be. He really is a virgin, what does he know on this topic? Wait, not only is he a virgin, but he has also repressed his sexuality and is really gay. Laugh at him for being a closeted homosexual who hasn't even had sex.
Hawkwild
Oh my God. Trump's "Facts of Life" talk was just mortifying. But not as mortifying as the Capital Edge presentation. It was actually more cringeworthy than the Primarius "street theater" billboard for Tide to Go on Apprentice: Martha, and that's saying something.

I don't think Clay's an anti-Semite, but I do think he's hopelessly tin-eared.
My Way

I'm Jewish. My friends tease me about how cheap I am all the time. I'm cheap. I'm cheap because my dad is cheap, because his parents were cheap, probably 'cause they grew up during the depression and were child of poor Jewish immigrants?
Yes, but hopefully friends call you cheap because...you all feel its true for a particular person (there are lots of cheap people around, after all)--not because they assume you're cheap because of some religious/ethnic stereotype.
When Clay says "...tight, Jewish boy..." that's just being bigoted.[/quote][/quote]
See, I think if Clay meant tight as in cheap, which I'm not convinced of, he could have been referring to Adam's comment that he is cheap. I mean, didn't he say something about not wanting to pay for dates? What the hell? The problem here, is that the atmosphere was too relaxed to be professional, and the presenters had trouble with boundaries. Adam is talking about how he's a jewish boy from atlanta and his dating thoughts, and Clay is talking about his experience with sexual harassment (boss slapping the ass)...they clearly needed to talk about this before hand and I think Clay and Adam were guilty to different degrees of being too familiar with the audience.

I still think both of them are leaps and bounds better than Markus and I think when Trump decides that there is no way in hell he will ever hire this person he just fires them, regardless of task performance. I think that's fine, it's his show.

I don't think hiring laws apply in Trump's world because I bet this show is sold as a game show and the job is not a job but a prize, worth 100k or something.
SmedIndy
Man, Clay's got a chip as big as he is on his shoulder. If it falls off it may crush Brian.

I had to pause the TiVo when Trump said "That's why restaurants have menus". It cracked the wife and me up so hard we had to compose ourselves.

Markus, Markus, Markus...SHADDAP YOUR MOUTH!
YoureSoUrban

Adam really made the whole thing so personal. He was so focused on "Clay made Jew comments, more than one Jew comment, he made Jew comments!" It was Clay's OTHER comments that probably caused more discomfort.[/quote]

I totally agree. The editors made a point of showing us crowd reactions when he was talking about looking at some guys ass, and someone smacking his. I don't recall similar treatment after Clay's other comments, just focus on Adam's surprise.



George interviews: Marcus is doing a great job as PM. He speaks well." Ay yiy yi. Chris Rock's voice was running through my brain on that one.[/quote]
Mine too.
ShutUpFlo

Marcus is the title character from Monthy Python's Anne Elk sketch.

Where? Oh, what is my theory? This is it. (clears throat at some length) My theory that belongs to me is as follows. (clears throat at great length) This is how it goes. The next thing I"m going to say is my theory. Ready?

Adam should have gone for the Phil Donahue impression because that's exactly how the presentation started.

I thought Alla was pushing Adam to kick out Clay instead of Marcus so that she'd get a Get Out Of The Boardroom Free card the next time the team screwed up. It was only when Marcus dug himself a verbal ditch did she dogpile. Smart play.
[/quote]

Just because this analogy is so dead on and deserves to be listened to:
Anne Elk
Zycron

Clay: "But remember, he's the shy, tight, Jewish boy."[/quote]
That's what I heard as well. I honestly thought he meant "tight" as in uptight, alluding to Adam's virginity. I assume his cherry is intact, as is his virtue. Perhaps Clay was just hinting that Adam's ass was too tight to crack open? At least not for another 10 years... Though Donald trying to school Adam on the joys of sex was quite comical.


Donald's "Are you a homosexual? Did you know he was a homosexual? Did you? Carolyn, you knew? Why didn't anybody tell me?"[/quote]
Ah Donald... no gaydar whatsoever.
Bassari99
I hope Clay was not trying to out Adam, especially in that context and in so condescendingly a manner. I think that would be so wrong, especially whenAdam had not declared his sexuality-- gay or straight-- to anyone on the show. I would find that scenario to be even more repugnant than Clay making a thoughtless racial gaffe. If that is what Clay was doing, I think it was incredibly mean-spirited.
Midnight Creeper
Judging by Kelly's rigid and glazed appearance, the latest Apprentice winners undergo some kind of Stepford process to turn them into robots. And not sexy ones, either.
mbridgii
Maybe I just have a dirty mind, but FocusedApathy's comments are exactly where I thought Clay was going. Especially seeing as though he had already gone too far into the danger zone for this topic.

While I don't believe Clay was thinking "tight" related to being Jewish, the use of the phrase, especially after the comment that Adam made just before, was the worst kind of bad timing. There are always going to be people who think that he meant "cheap", and I'm sure he doesn't want the repercussions that the one woman in S2 faced with her "fat Jewish ladies" comment.

Randal is the man! While Chris Rock immediately came to me with George's "speaks so well" comment, I prefer to look at it as Randal being, indeed, a very dynamic speaker period. I knew that he was going to be successful with the "How to Stand Out" series; even though it was not "sexy" enough for the less-original members of his team. It's very easy to go in with a sensational topic and get attention. It's just as easy to fall flat on your face trying to live up to the hype (ask Capital Edge). The same way that the team doubted Craig last season, with his utility box, is what happened here. I know this is TV, but these people need to learn that flashy subject matter isn't always necessary. What's important is how dynamic the speaker is.

Given the whole Clay-Adam debacle, a class in interpersonal communication might not have been a bad idea (maybe they should take the class first). Notice how one sentence spoken by Clay has caused so much discord and confusion: some think he was referring to Adam as a "cheap Jew"; others thinking he meant "Jewish boy with stick up his tuchus".

What could Clay have done differently? Did Adam make a snap judgment? Was Clay's "apology" sincere? This is an interesting subject that does not require talk about patting people's buttocks. Yet they went down the path of trying to titillate the crowd.
Bulldog
On tonight's very special episode of The Apprentice, The Donald teaches young Adam about the joyous wonders of sexual relationships.

OMG! I truly thought they could not top last week's boardroom, but they somehow managed. So much awkwardness. So many inappropriate comments. I hardly know where to begin.

My love for Carolyn knows no bounds. She totally nailed the mystery that is Markus. While there was certainly an argument to be made for firing Clay, I probably would have gone with Markus as well. He was such a completely worthless tool. However, I do think he had a point as he left the boardroom. Trump has clearly had a bullseye on him since the very beginning. I'm totally surprised he made it this far.

As for Clay and Adam, I honestly do not believe there was anything even remotely anti-semitic in Clay's remarks. Adam brought up his Jewishness (is that a word?) and referenced it several times. What did that have to do with sex in the workplace? For that matter, what did being from Atlanta have to do with it? I think Adam saw an opportunity to play victim and took advantage of it, which was shrewd on his part. I don't think he was honestly offended. I do, however, think George was offended and I wonder what he thinks of Trump firing Markus over Clay.

Does Adam remind anyone else of Ross Geller?

Steak and spaghetti. At least it wasn't hot dogs and tacos.

Favorite non-boardroom moment: Randal having to almost bend double to hug Brian when he switched teams.

Second favorite: The prolonged wait for the missing foursome.

Third: Trump totally forgetting Kelly's last name.

I didn't really get the whole concept of the sex in the workplace theme. Was this suppose to be about workplace dating? Sexual harassment? Or was it just advocating having sex at work?

Marshawn handled the microphone like every beauty queen I have ever seen with a microphone in her hand. Do they teach them that somewhere?

Predicted final four: Randall, Rebecca, Alla, Marshawn. Darkhorse: Brian
I really don't see anyone else having a chance.

ETA: Couldn't the whole debate over what Clay said to Adam have been settled by Carolyn who was supposedly there when the comment was made?
PopCultDiva
Regarding the "Jew" comment: I came in at the Boardroom, heard what Adam said and was appropriately shocked. Then my (8-year old) baby and I watched the ep from the beginning and both of us were singing "no he did not say tight Jew" to the TV. We really didn't see that Clay had committed any grievous crimes.

Then the following changed my mind:


Seriously, on the subject of whether or not it was okay for Clay to jump on Adam's "I'm a cheap Jew" train: it was not. My dad lost his last job for doing a similar thing in front of an African American audience. In a professional setting, when you're around people unlike you in some vital and sensitive way, and they're joking about themselves, you don't get to join in.[/quote]

So true. Even though Clay's comment was completely different from what Adam though it was, Clay shouldn't have "jumped on the train". If, particularly in a public forum, I had said in a self-deprecating way something about being black with my manager then deciding to "jump on the train", I would have been seriously pissed.

In other Apprentice news:

1 - When strategizing in a room with three other people who have WON as PM, Rebecca, you are in NO position to shoot down ideas. Just to remind, you were the one who thought TORAL(!!!) was worth keeping around. Just keep quiet, execute well and pray that takes you to final four, like others on this board feel is your due.

2 - Agree that Randall is on track to winning. His plan of doing something average really well (as opposed to doing in something spectacular mediocre) is so in keeping with what Bill and Kelly did, to winning effect. And you gotta figure, a guy with five degrees is going to know what makes an interesting class!

3 - My baby was thrilled to see that the reward was Michael Kors from Project Runway (Folks, meet my child, Reality-Show PopCultDiva Kid - oddly it's the only non-kid TV I allow her to watch). I was kind of meh about it. However I was really impressed with the clothes. Or was it just that Marshawn and Rebecca looked way better than I ever could in his stuff? And for the record, I liked Marshawn's brown ruffled pants. They are exactly what you could get away with wearing in New York, so why not?
intrepide

page 1: Markus is a human dispenser of word salad. A stream of conscienciousness set on shuffle.[/quote]

page 7: Markus. Damn. He is so Rain Main. Suffering from a forty year drought.[/quote]
MarchingOcelot and heebiejeebie you crack me up. I'll be laughing out loud like a fool for the next day.

When Trump was having the sex talk with Adam, I was so uncomfortable that I changed the channel for a couple of seconds until I remembered that there might be entertaining moments to be seen.

I think the theme of this episode was "It's uncomfortable to watch someone be inappropriate." By my count: Clay, Trump (Adam), Trump (Clay), and then Markus. Can anyone make this two pair or a full house?
tiggeril

I didn't really get the whole concept of the sex in the workplace theme. Was this suppose to be about workplace dating? Sexual harassment? Or was it just advocating having sex at work?
[/quote]
I think they just stopped at the seventh-period study hall idea of "Let's talk about sex! Teehee! Aren't we naughty?" They kind of forgot that an overarching theme is not enough.
Juliebijoux

Exact quotes from the episode:

Adam: "Speaking about first dates...You know what's great about dinner, is that you have great conversation, but I have to feel really comfortable with the person, and I also have to be willing to spend the money."

Clay: "But remember, he's the shy, tight, Jewish boy."

Adam: *nervous laughter* Um... *more nervous laughter* So...yeah!"

Like I said originally, I didn't think it was a mortal sin in the jokey atmosphere they were going for (Manhattan might not be the best crowd), but there was no doubt that Clay was calling him a cheap Jew bastard. [/quote]

There is a doubt in my mind. To me it sounds like Adam is saying that he is not focused on sex during the first date. Clay seems be of the school that it is normal to have casual sex. Adam is not the mainstream.

Actually the part where his whole team and later DT basically sort of put him down for that fact that he is uncomfortable with sex made me cringe more than the whole Jewish debacle. In the BR Adam told DT that he took an unconfortable situation and made it his own, but I didn't see Adam having any control. He could have delegated the talking to other members of the team (hello, Alla?) Why did he feel the need to keep repeating that he's a "nice Jewish boy?"

FocusedApathy I agree that Clay meant tight assed in the not into sex way. I don't know if he was implying that Adam is gay. But that is an interesting interpretation. I just think that Adam is totally uncomfortable with sex. He seems almost asexual.
Rowr17

At least it wasn't hot dogs and tacos. [/quote]

Bulldog, that is one of my favorite SNL skits ever. I would have given DT a lot of props if he had used hot dogs and tacos instead of steak and spaghetti.
AwNutz
Someone upthread mentioned that Clay was outed by Adam or Markus. Not really. IIRC, he outed himself as the first gay interviewee on the Apprentice in the first epi where they introduce themselves. He's never hidden it, and all the others in the boardroom made it clear that they knew he was gay. Of course, you have to have the weakest gaydar ever to have not picked up on that fact....
Obladi

He practically did throw one, on the way back up to and entering the suite.[/quote]

He was probably upset about any number of elements. Almost being fired, being accused of anti-Semitism, and hearing that his bringing up homosexuality somehow caused them to lose even though every part of their presentation was horrible.


Clay said that Adam is a "tight-*ss Jew". He used the word Jew, and itwas in response to Adam mentioning not wanting to pay for something.[/quote]

I remember him saying 'tight Jewish boy', which was dumb, but I never heard him say 'tight ass Jew.' Alla and Adam claimed he made several remarks about Jews, but they never bothered to elaborate. All I heard was 'tight Jewish boy', which was an extension of Adam's own comments. I do know that everyone hears this in their own way, so maybe I'm wrong.


Actually, I believe he said, "If I have to apologize to you, then I'm sorry." He didn't feel he said anything wrong.[/quote]

If he didn't feel he said anything wrong he probably never would have apologized. I thought he said if he had offended Adam, he was sorry. I don't remember the exact words, but even then he may have realized Adam was going to set this up as an issue to save his skin after he did such a bad job as PM.

I don't think Clay was trying to 'out' Adam. I think they probably don't discuss each other's sexual identifications, this does not seem like a cast who sit around and talk about their personal lives.
mrsmere66
Oh MY GAWD. This is still the best show on T.V., just for the drop your mouth open, throw your head back, and laugh like a loon ability. My teenager and I were yelling at the t.v., pausing things on TiVo to see it again, and laughing some more.

Donald - yeah, I SO need you to teach me about sensitivity and virginity and the dangers of sex and how Adam or anyone else will be good at it in ten years. Shut the fuck up. You are such a weird ass I can't even stand it. I hate you so much that I love you. Carolyn looked downright mortified whenever Donald played the "SexFather" to Adam.

Randall - you can take off your shirt on national t.v. anytime. Damn!

Carolyn - my 15 year old son took one look at you in that dress and said, "How old is she, anyway?" I mean, girlfriend, the prom dress look was about 20 years ago for you. You made me yell out loud.

Kelly - what the hell are you still doing working for Trump? He likes people who yell and make an ass of himself on an airplane and think that they are better than everyone else in the world and that gives them the right to.... oh wait, that's right - TRUMP. Got it.

Alla - you are a player girlfriend. I would love to see you in a final two smackdown with Randall. It would be the good vs. evil show down of all time.


I thought Randall and Marshawn et al had a wonderful little session. I would have loved to have been there. Had an outline, had a survey, had small group time... fabulous. I need Randall in my boardroom. And no, that wasn't dirty.
kyriebelle
Edited because although I am a dumbass, I am no Markus.

I agree that Markus is a complete tool, but I believe he was absolutely correct when right after the class they were standing right outside the classroom and Adam was calling Clay out on his shit, and Markus said several times "Let's wait until later." Although it was extremely inappropriate for Clay to make the comments he did, it is also not cool or very professional to call him out and chew his ass in front of customers (which, basically, is what the class group was). IMHO, they all acted like asses.
YoureSoUrban

I just think that Adam is totally uncomfortable with sex. He seems almost asexual.[/quote]
I tend to agree. When the team first, and lightly, brought up the subject Adam physically recoiled at the word "sex". My goodness, there's bemused embarrassment, even shock, but this was repulsion. I sense something deeper going on with him and empathize since he's now having to work some of it out on national TV.
tiggeril
I would have reacted the same way only a few short years ago. Part of being raised in an extremely old-fashioned home.
chartreuse

I mean when sitting through lectures at Oxford and MIT and one or two other places long enough to get five degrees you have to learn something about good educational presentation.[/quote]Never mind sitting through courses, he's almost certainly taught them before. And you don't get through the Rhodes scholarship interview process itself without being a dynamic speaker.

I agree with all who believe that Clay didn't mean to be offensive when he made his comment to Adam; but it doesn't really matter what he meant. In a public speaking situation, what matters is what the audience thinks you meant. If half, or a quarter, or a tenth of the people reading this forum thought that Clay was offensive, then chances are that at least one person sitting in that room listening to them thought it was offensive. And that one person taking out their anger with a grade of "1" instead of a "7" could have lost them the challenge.

Also, it's too bad that the whole awkward boardroom focussed on issues other than the task itself. Even if there had been no Jewish / gay comments in the presentation, it still sucked. It had no outline. It had no breaking up into groups to allow audience participation. It made no sense. I suspect they got the marks they did because the audience was just so shocked by how ridiculous it was that combined with the video cameras they were just waiting for it to appear on reality TV somewhere.
mistahtrump
The Clay remark was totally blown out of proportion. Yes, it was stupid, and yes it was ill-timed. It's one of those "wish you could take it back, but can't" lines (well for most sane people, at least...I'm sure Clay thought it was absolutely brilliant). However, I am glad that it didn't cost him his shot at being Trump's professional food taster...he was trying to pick up cues from Adam's tired "I'm just a Jewish Caveman" routine, and just executed it very poorly. In the boardroom I was half expecting Adam to bust out into Woody Allen's Alvy Singer and start saying "JEW, no not 'did you,' he said JEW!"

Believe me, I hate Clay. He's a sanctimonious, arrogant little bitch ("Josh's words, not mine), but hey, isn't that true of most of the great corporate leaders of our time? You think Steve Jobs is winning any personality contests? Larry Ellison? Clay would respond with an affirmative "I don't think so!" Randal has this in the bag, and I don't think Clay has a George's chance at a Wet T-shirt contest of becoming TA4. But as project manager on the Dairy Queen task, he was all business, and he delivered a solid win. So he has some modicum of talent, and deserves to live to see another day.

And then we come to Markus, markus, marked man...Trumpy and the Viceroys had your number since day one, when you rambled incoherently at the Friars Club lunch and delivered your "stream of consciousness on shuffle" (props to whoever came up with that one) bit on the etymology of the team name "Excel." I mean, the only person who liked you was was TORAL, distinguished from Assorama only by her Wharton degree and belief in a God that doesn't like stupid ambiguous costumes (thanks for making the rest of us Indian American Hindus look like shit, Toral.) I despise Bitchface Carolyn, but damn did she put the smackdown with that "Cover Your Ass" line to Markus.

I wanted to feel sorry for him, but he really erased any "goodwill" (to borrow his words) I had for him with his snappy "if you mean it" retort to the Trumpster, and puffing on that cigar indignantly on the terrace. After skewering his colleagues on their sexual experience and preference, I thought Combover let Markus off pretty easy. Yet, he had to be his stupid, incoherent self to the very end. As one other poster pointed out, even Omagrosa slinked out of there with more dignity.

Farewell Markus -- you have unseated Sam Solovey as the most self-deluded, idiotic buffoon ever to sleep in the Love Palace.

ps -- Adam, my man, I felt so bad for you -- you've flown under the radar successfully all season, only to have your religion and lack of sexual experience paraded all over town like Melania and her denim-clad ass. But you handled it with dignity, and earned points from me. Delcious wishes for you!
Magsi2

Man, Clay's got a chip as big as he is on his shoulder. If it falls off it may crush Brian.[/quote]
I shouldn't have, but it made me LOL! Good one.
anwen
See, I didn't hear Adam say he doesn't like to pay for dates at all, just that a dinner date is a larger investment (financially and emotionally) than whatever they were talking about at the time (presumably work flirtations of some sort). Which in writing sounds like splitting hairs, but I didn't think of it as "he doesn't like to pay for dates" at all until I read posts here--I heard it as, "If I take someone on a dinner date, it's because I really like them,"--possibly as opposed to someone he might just flirt with at work.

It also seems to me like one of those uneven situations, where it's one thing to refer to oneself as something, and another thing for someone to grant themselves permission to do so. I mean, I occasionally used to refer to myself as a "nice Christian girl," in a joking context, but if I were discussing something in a professional context and someone cut me off with a similar comment, I would find that innappropriate. I wouldn't necessarily assume that said person is anti-Christian--nor do I think Clay is anti-Semetic. But in this situation, in front of a large audience, it was just stupid. It falls into the kind of thing that you can joke about with your friends, but not all those things are workplace appropriate. A friend tells me that for a nice Christian girl I have a sick twisted mind? I laugh. A colleague insists on assuming that, for instance, I wouldn't compile information on gay adoptions because he knew I was Christian and therefore must be homophobic? (That really happened, BTW) is being an asshole, and got called for it--despite his protestations that the fact people knew I was Christian meant his concerns were totally legitimate. I realize that this whole presentation was much less formal than most workplace encounters, but it was still a professional setting--and even if there hadn't been the "Jewish" aspect, it still seemed like a way to demean a fellow presenter in front of your audience.

Incidentally, I love George for saying that executives should be sensitive--not as a wishy-washy PC thing, but simply because it makes sense. There's no point in needlessly offending someone, and defending your right to do so, or your opinion that they "shouldn't" have been offended is just bad business among other things. And Clay lost a lot of points from me with his, "If I need to apologize, than I do so," type comment, because to me, that's not an apology at all.

I also frankly don't care if he's [Adam, that is, not George! Not that I want to think about George's sex life either] a virgin or not. Then again, I was a virgin until I got married, and I helped run anti-date rape workshops and the mandatory safe-sex workshops at my school, so "virgin" doesn't equal "scared of discussing TEH SEX!" to me. On the other hand, I wouldn't be comfortable teaching a class like that--which seemed to me to have very little structure or planning--with people who seemingly had no specific credentials--I mean, what, they've had sex at work? Whoo for them. It just seems to me like a stupid concept unless it was actually grounded in something like understanding sexual harrassment--which admittedly would not be a terribly exciting class. And, for example, the issue of Clay's comments about homosexuality suggests to me they planned very little. Which isn't to say, at all, that homosexuality shouldn't be discussed in "Sex in the Cubicle" or whatever the class was, but it does suggest to me that they didn't discuss beforehand what they might say. I wasn't offended by his comments about co-workers "slapping his ass" or whatever it was, but it's conceivable to me that some people might be made uncomfortable by that, and in this setting, it seems to me like something he should have been aware with. (Then again, sometimes it seems like I spend way too much time trying to convince straight guys that, no, dear, that one gay guy you know actually ISN'T constantly checking you out and attempting to seduce you--and from the comments that we saw, I would be concerned about whether that was feeding that kind of stereotype--and if I were on the team, yeah, I might feel that wasn't the smartest way to handle said topic, particularly when being graded a subjective scale. It's one thing to have a "provocative" topic to get people into the class, but I would think they would have considered the risk of "provoking" people into giving them bad reviews.
Lisetta

I just think that Adam is totally uncomfortable with sex. He seems almost asexual.[/quote]
Could be. But in the work place (even if you're just "working" on tv as a contestant to be Trump's apprentice), it's no one's business. The boss doesn't mention it, doesn't tease you about it or offer unsolicited advice, much less publicly do all that.

I used to like Trump during TA1, even TA2. But having read so much about him the past couple of years, I've become very disgusted by him. He can, undoubtedly, turn on the charm when and where he chooses. But as an employer (or a person)? Definitely, I'd avoid him and his actions re: Clay and Adam just make him more repulsive than ever.

It's sad to me to see someone who acts like he does be so "successful" and, frankly, so...rich. Somehow...really too bad. Because isolated as he is, he'll never learn.
ladyveg
Unless I missed this in his bio or something, Adam never said he was a virgin. Did he? I thought the Hair just assumed it. I'm seeing a nice-looking, well-educated, physically fit young man who dresses well and appears to have good social skills. I'd do him myself. Maybe he has been laid a zillion times and just has more class than The Donald, who was all, "Uh huh huh...Someday, Beavis, you'll have urges, like I do. Uh huh huh."

Somehow I couldn't see TD saying, "Rebecca, have you ever had sex?" And if she refused to answer, would he assume the answer was no?


Re: Clay at the workshop, I think he is someone who needs to follow a strict outline when doing any public speaking, otherwise he falls into an act. He was playing the Snarky Flaming Gay Guy who makes Sassy Comments, and expects his supposed pushing the envelope to make the audience gasp and think he's hilarious and daring. Like, everyone else is being so boring, we're going to lose the audience if they're just sitting there learning and not paying attention to ME BEING FUNNY! THEY LOVE ME! I AM THE FUNNIEST GAY GUY EVER! NO ONE ELSE WOULD SAY WHAT I'M SAYING!

I also didn't buy Donald's comment that he didn't know Clay was gay. I read that as kind of a "You're an albino?! Why, no, I never ever noticed! Wow, it's because I just see how people are on the inside and I never ever pay attention to that petty stuff. Hey, nothing wrong with that! Pink is one of my favorite eye colors! Look at you!"

"Gee, you're gay? Nothing wrong with that, nothing at all, no sir! Rainbows are awesome! It's like a menu, you know? I like models, ha ha! Girl models! But you like guy models! They're hot in a different way, not to me though, ha ha! It's like steak and spaghetti! You're all noble and persecuted and could never be prejudiced against another person!"

I'd better lay off the caffeine. My apologies.

Forgot--I know the comments were hand-picked to be dramatically different for each team, but the scores were incredibly close. I found that interesting. I would have liked to hear at least one positive for Adam's team and one negative for Randal's.
tiggeril
Hee! Between your caffeine and my cold medicine, we're a whirlwind of TA theories!
BlakeSpeare
Personally, there's no way I can believe it was purely a coincidence that Clay made a remark about Adam being a "tight Jewish boy" immediately after Adam made a comment about not wanting to spend money.

I'm Jewish myself, and as soon as Adam made the comment about not wanting to spend the money to go out to dinner, I thought to myself, "Did you really have to reinforce that negative stereotype?" It was an easy opportunity to make a dumb joke, and Clay took the bait.

If Clay had made a joke about Adam being a tight Jewish boy after Adam said something about his squeamishness regarding sex, then I'd assume Clay meant tight as in "uptight." But since Adam's previous comment was about money, IMO it would have been downright bizarre for Clay to mention something about Adam being uptight about sex.

If I ever make a comment about not wanting to spend money, and someone calls me being a tight Jewish boy, I'm going to assume they meant I was cheap. But that's just me.
Summa
Best, most gratifying firing since Assorama. Don't get me wrong. The boardroom last week rocked, and it was absolutely fantastic. But this one was so much more gratifying and it was wonderful on an intimate basis, where last week was wonderful on a Grand Canyon basis.
rcpubdef98
Edited for grammar I can't help but think that Markus suffered stage fright being in front of the cameras. I don't think this is like AI where they intentionally put people in front of the judges to make a fool of themselves. I think, off-camera, Markus is probably not as anti-semantic as he showed.

I thought Clay's comment was more damaging in that it threw Adam completely off during the presentation. Adam redeemed himself in the boardroom. He read the room well, answered the questions eloquently and succinctly, and remained respectful at all times even when put in the most Un!Comfortable! position of having to answer questions about his sex life.
Brent724

Best, most gratifying firing since Assorama. Don't get me wrong. The boardroom last week rocked, and it was absolutely fantastic. But this one was so much more gratifying and it was wonderful on an intimate basis, where last week was wonderful on a Grand Canyon basis.[/quote]

LOL, I felt the same way. I've been wanting Markus gone since Week 2. Ugh. Now Clay and then I will be happy.
Swallow
And here I thought I would never see a cab ride funnier than last week's. I'm so glad this show comes on after the currently depressing Survivor.

Carolyn on Markus: He removes himself from the task, waits for the task to fail, and then says, "I told you so." She had him dead to rights. I loved her this week.

I want to work for Alla and be her bitch. She's so bad, and hard, and just handles people. She kind of scares me and gets me excited at the same time.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.